Simon gives ‘awkward’ guy a second chance, and he captivates judges with an impressive comeback

Edduin Carvajal
Oct 09, 2018
10:34 A.M.
Share this pen

Andrew Scholz was only 18 years old when he went to the “X Factor” back in 2013. Even though he was labeled as “awkward,” his comeback wowed the audience.


In the third season of the show, the judges were Kelly Rowland, Demi Lovato, Paulina Rubio, and Simon Cowell. When Andrew got onstage, his physique captivated the female members of the audience and the judges.

While he was wearing clothes that most country musicians would choose, he started singing Alex Clare’s pop song “Too Close.” His decision surprised the judges, and after a couple of seconds, Demi and Kelly stopped the presentation.

They said that Andrew looked like if he was in a karaoke show and that it was awkward. They made sure to point out that his voice wasn’t necessarily bad, though.


All three female judges had something negative to say, but Simon noticed something different in Andrew, so he gave him a second chance. Andrew chose “A Little More You” by Little Big Town, and things were completely different.

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global


It was like if the song made him feel more secure on the stage and, since his voice was always there, Paulina, Demi, and Kelly really enjoyed his presentation. When he finished, Demi pointed out that it “totally changed everything.”

Read more on our Twitter account, @amomama_usa.

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global


Simon looked at the other three judges like if he was saying: “I told you.” After getting three yeses, Simon told Andrew that his career should be focused on country music because it was what came out naturally for him and gave him the fourth yes.

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global

Source: YouTube/X Factor Global


Later in the competition, Andrew joined Colton Pack and Zach Beeken to form the band Restless Road that ended in the 4th place of the show.

It was not the only time that Simon gave a contestant a second chance, though, as he did the same with "America's Got Talent' singer Johnny Manuel.


He chose Stevie Wonder’s hit “Lately,” and even though he did a pretty good job, Simon made him choose another tune as he considered his performance was “annoying.”

Johnny then chose Whitney Houston’s version of “I Have Nothing,” and blew everyone away. Seal, one of the judges, was so impressed that he even hit the golden buzzer.

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

Boy with Prosthesis Is Denied by Soccer Team, Next Day Captain Personally Invites Him to Join – Story of the Day

May 07, 2022

On Valentine's Day, Rich Girl Rejects Poor Guy, She Appears on His Doorstep Years Later – Story of the Day

February 14, 2022

Boy Runs into Huge Box on Doorstep in the Winter Cold, Hears Loud Cry from Inside — Story of the Day

February 01, 2022

Late Soldier Asked Son to Bring US Flag to His Grave, Boy Does and Finds Envelope There – Story of the Day

April 16, 2022

Visiting Widowed Mom after 3 Years, Man Finds a Mess and Hears a Man Coughing in the Next Room — Story of the Day

March 24, 2022

Before Major Surgery Veteran Gives Nurse a Badge Begging to Find and Bring His Best Friend – Story of the Day

May 03, 2022

Man Drags Friend on Wheelchair to Top of Mountain So He Can Scatter His Wife’s Ashes – Story of the Day

May 23, 2022

Teacher Notices a Change in Little Boy's Behavior and Soon Finds a Note Asking for Help – Story of the Day

February 14, 2022

14-Year-Old Boy Approaches His Poor Single Father and Says, 'Dad, I Found Mom' – Story of the Day

February 07, 2022

On Valentine’s Day, Old Lady Who Barely Recognizes Her Kids Meets Man She Lost 56 Years Ago — Story of the Day

February 15, 2022

Teen Boy Assists Blind Old Woman in Crossing the Road and Receives Inheritance from Her Later – Story of the Day

February 04, 2022

Julie Andrews Misses Her Husband 'like Crazy' after Trying to Save Him from the 'Monster' of Self-Medication

May 11, 2022

Boy Who Lost Faith after Parents' Death Goes to Church for Help for the First Time in Years – Story of the Day

January 26, 2022

Woman Takes Bullet for Stranger’s Son, His Dad Attends Funeral and Meets 9 Crying Kids There — Story of the Day

March 23, 2022