logo

Bill Cosby's lawyers dispute '11 mistakes' judge made in sentencing famous actor to jail

Jaimie-lee Prince
By Jaimie-lee Prince
Dec 12, 2018
03:13 P.M.

Bill Cosby's lawyers are persisting with a new motion alleging 11 errors occurred during his trial.

Advertisement

Disgraced actor Bill Cosby is currently sitting in a suburban Philadelphia prison just 20 miles from his home. He may serve three to ten years in prison for sexual assault.

Cosby's lawyers recently appealed for the former comedian to be released from prison but to no avail. They are now going after the judge's methods throughout the trial that put Cosby where he is.

Follow us on Twitter for more @amomama.

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images

According to NY Daily News, the lawyers allege that Judge Steven O'Neill did several things wrong when he convicted Cosby in September. The 81-year-old was found guilty of drugging and sexually assaulting Andrew Constand, his mentee, in 2004.

Advertisement

Legal experts assert that O'Neill did not divulge a feud he had with one of the pretrial witnesses who had previously failed to charge Cosby in 2008.

Brian Perry, Cosby's current lawyer, released a statement. It read:

"The trial court erred in failing to disclose his bias against District Attorney (Bruce) Castor, and in failing to recuse himself, prior to determining (his) credibility."

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images

According to Perry, another mistake the judge made was to have five other women accusing Cosby speak at the trial. In 2017, those same women were not allowed to testify.

Advertisement

At that time, the jury deadlocked. Yet in September, O'Neill gave no explanation for their inclusion which was previously considered "too remote in time" and "too dissimilar" to Constand's experience.

Perry further alleges that O'Neill's dismissal of a binding "agreement" between Cosby and Castor was faulty. The actor was never to be charged against based on Castor's decision in 2005.

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images

In comparison, O'Neill allowed readings from Cosby's 2005 deposition to be read. This happened despite a settlement of $3.4 million that was paid to Constand at the time.

Advertisement

The deposition indicated that Cosby confessed to giving Quaaludes to some women before he had sex with them. This was a major factor in the decision made by jurors in finding Cosby guilty.

If the appeal doesn't stand, Cosby may have to wait 10 years until he can get parole. Upon release, he would have to register as an offender since the judge formally deemed him a "sexually violent predator."

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images

The backlash of Cosby's actions is not only coming from inside the courtroom. The actor is also being blamed for diminishing holiday cheer.

Advertisement

The classic holiday song "Baby, It's Cold Outside" was found to encourage date rape by some listeners. Many stations pulled the song from the air.

Songwriter Frank Loesser's daughter Susan blamed it all on Cosby saying "Bill Cosby ruined it for everybody."

Source: Getty Images

Source: Getty Images

The 74-year-old said that since the accusations arose, she has been hearing "the date rape thing all the time." She also insists that people should consider the song's historical context.

Meanwhile, Cosby is reportedly working as an "unofficial life coach" behind bars. He listens to fellow inmates and advises them, much like his 12 lawyers so far have advised him.

It waits to be seen whether or not this new appeal will stand against the judge that changed the life of a person who used to be "America's Dad."

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts

Texas Jury Reaches Verdict in Karmelo Anthony Case After 3 Hours — His Mother Pleads for Mercy

June 09, 2026

Karmelo Anthony Remains Emotionless as Verdict Is Read While Family Breaks Down — Details

June 10, 2026

FedEx Driver Who Took 7-Year-Old Girl's Life Learns His Fate in Court, Responds with Single Word

May 05, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's Mother Ignites Buzz with Rare Statement on Legal Drama

June 10, 2026

FedEx Driver's Disturbing Past Revealed in Court – What His Mother Testified

April 23, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's Grandmother Ignites Reactions Over Hand Symbols

June 11, 2026

Legal Proceedings Continue as Court Hears Emotional Evidence in Athena Strand Case

April 17, 2026

Photos Show Karmelo Anthony and His Family's Lavish Life Before Legal Incident – Details

June 11, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's Parents Speak Out on Legal Battle After Verdict, Revealing What Their Family Faces Daily

June 11, 2026

Donald Trump Pays Over $5.6 Million to Author Who Sued Him

July 15, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's New Legal Team Outlines Next Steps After His Conviction — Here's What They're Now Targeting

June 24, 2026