logo

Florida Dad Accused of Dropping 5-Year-Old Daughter off a Bridge May Be Spared Jail

Gracious Egedegbe
By Gracious Egedegbe
Mar 18, 2019
10:43 P.M.

Florida man, Jonchuck, who was accused of killing his daughter after throwing her 62feet deep into the Tampa Bay bridge on January 8, 2015, is set to plead insanity as a defense.

Advertisement

The first class murder trial for Jonchuck begins after a four-year-long wait for the accused whose trial was delayed because he was formerly incompetent to face trial.

Jonchuck, who was a victim of public criticism after he killed 5-year-old Phoebe claims that he heard "voices" instructing him to throw the young girl off the bridge.

Advertisement

When the police finally caught up with him on the night of the murder, he explained that he obeyed the "voices" because he was afraid that his disobedience would hurt everyone else and make them go to hell.

Saying weird things with biblical allusions in such a manner that made no sense was something Jonchuck was known for. His divorce attorney, Genevieve Torres recalled that he called her office several times to say weird biblical things. His mother also told the police that her son dealt with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.

Advertisement

Jonchuck's attorneys, following this evidence and more have prepared their client to claim insanity as his defense for killing his daughter.

Jonchuck's hearing will be done under Judge Chris Helinger and 12 jurors at the Pinellas Justice Center in Clearwater, Florida.

Bob Dillinger, a Pinellas County Public Defender in an interview with Tampa Bay Times stated the odds of Jonchuck's case. According to him, going scot-free after claiming mental impairment for the first-degree murder in Florida is a very rare happening.

Advertisement

He added that since the prosecutors on Jonchuck's case were not seeking the death penalty, Jonchuck will go to prison for life if convicted and if not, he would be put in a state hospital for the rest of his life.

Advertisement

And if none of these two happen, Jonchuck's case might be handled like that of the Australian man who threw his daughter into a bridge some years ago. Even though he claimed insanity, he was convicted on the ground that he killed his daughter to spite his wife with whom he was having a serious divorce battle at the time. He was sentenced to 32 years non-parole prison term.

For Jonchuck, success, in this case, will be an acquittal but for this to happen, his attorneys have to do a good job to convince the court that their client was mentally ill at the time of the murder.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts

Alex Murdaugh Legal Battle Takes Shocking Turn After New Court Ruling

May 14, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's New Legal Team Outlines Next Steps After His Conviction — Here's What They're Now Targeting

June 24, 2026

Karmelo Anthony Remains Emotionless as Verdict Is Read While Family Breaks Down — Details

June 10, 2026

FedEx Driver Who Took 7-Year-Old Girl's Life Learns His Fate in Court, Responds with Single Word

May 05, 2026

Karmelo Anthony's Parents Speak Out on Legal Battle After Verdict, Revealing What Their Family Faces Daily

June 11, 2026

Teens Targeted 7 Family Members in Violent Incident – Relatives Describe Tensions and Possible Motive

July 16, 2026

Anna Kepner Case: Father Calls for Arrest After Stepbrother Charged as Adult, Released Pretrial

April 15, 2026

Family Fundraiser for Assistance Vanishes as Karmelo Anthony Files Notice of Appeal Without Attorney

June 12, 2026

Track Star's Legal Battle: Court Documents Expose Shocking Timeline – Photos

June 10, 2026

Former NFL Player Darron Lee Faces Murder Charges After What He Told Police at Scene

June 12, 2026

Photos Show Karmelo Anthony and His Family's Lavish Life Before Legal Incident – Details

June 11, 2026