logo
twitter.com/consequence
twitter.com/consequence

Jerry Stiller Almost Declined Role of George Costanza's Father in 'Seinfeld'

Jaimie-lee Prince
By Jaimie-lee Prince
May 13, 2020
05:40 A.M.

Jerry Stiller passed away on Monday, May 11. Not many knew that he almost wasn't a part of the show that would arguably become his greatest achievement.

Advertisement

Jerry Stiller may not have been the main character on the hit sitcom, "Seinfeld," but he was certainly a favorite for many viewers of the popular comedy show. Interestingly, he nearly missed the opportunity.

When he died of natural causes at age 92, fans were left reeling at the loss. Stiller reportedly died in the early hours of May 11, leaving behind a daughter, Amy, a son, Ben, and two grandchildren.

Advertisement

A HARD PASS ON 'SEINFELD'

Over a decade ago, Stiller revealed that he initially declined the part of George Constanza on "Seinfeld." The actor recalled how he was offered the role, to which he responded, "Who's Seinfeld?"

The producers told him that the show was currently on-air and is very funny, yet Stiller had his own things going on. "And I said, 'Well, I am in a Broadway show. I am about to rehearse. I pass. [They said] 'What?!' I pass."

Ben Stiller and his father, Jerry Stiller, attend party hosted by NBC at Sconset Playhouse on June 19, 1998 in Massachusetts | Photo: Getty Images

Ben Stiller and his father, Jerry Stiller, attend party hosted by NBC at Sconset Playhouse on June 19, 1998 in Massachusetts | Photo: Getty Images

Advertisement

READY FOR HIS BIG ROLE

Stiller's role was passed onto John Randolph. Unfortunately for him, his portrayal fell flat. So six months later, Larry David, "Seinfeld" co-creator," again approached Stiller.

Now that the Broadway show was done, Stiller opted in. He was told to play a mild-mannered Frank Constanza who had to succumb to the screaming Mrs. Constanza (Estelle Harris) constantly.

Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara attend the "58th Annual Tony Awards" on June 6, 2004, in New York City. | Source: Getty Images.

Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara attend the "58th Annual Tony Awards" on June 6, 2004, in New York City. | Source: Getty Images.

SWITCHING THINGS UP

Advertisement

At first, Stiller did as told. But soon enough, he realized he'd probably get fired too because the stage was just too dull. Also, the bald cap wasn't working out for him.

Stiller recalled "when we shot the dress rehearsal before we go on stage with a live audience, she started screaming at me, and I out of instinct, instead of just saying my lines, I [screamed back]."

Everyone around began laughing, and David encouraged Stiller to continue the impromptu practice. Also, he didn't have to wear the cap either. Stiller partially credits the show's success with a lack of sticking to the script.

STILLER CLOSES OFF EPISODE

Advertisement

Plus, the gang genuinely liked each other. No doubt Stiller's fellow castmates loved when the actor gave his classic yells coupled with hilarious lines.

One such episode was "The Fusilli Jerry" in season six. After Constanza thinks Kramer's using his moves, he ends up nearly falling and going to a chiropractor. "A million to one, doc!" he closes off at the end.

'SEINFELD' CO-STAR PAYS TRIBUTE

Following his death, former co-star Jason Alexander paid tribute to Stiller in a touching tweet on Monday, May 11. "A great actor, a great man, a lovely friend," wrote Alexander, who played George Constanza.

The post garnered over 9,100 comments and more than 142k likes as fans showed solidarity with the actor. Our hearts go out to all those affected by the death and our condolences to the family.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts

Richard Gere's Wife Shows the Faces of Their Sons for the First Time

May 12, 2026

American Singer Oliver Tree, 32, Among 6 Dead in Rio Helicopter Collision — Here's What We Know

June 14, 2026

Why Jimmy Bullard, 47, and David Haye, 45, Were Reportedly Removed from 'I'm a Celebrity' Final – Video That Sparked Buzz

April 27, 2026

A-List Star Spotted Laughing With Her Rumored Actor Boyfriend Hours After Her Family Announced a Heartbreaking Loss — Photos

July 17, 2026

He Was a Star of a Hit '90s TV Series Loved by Everyone — What Happened to Him?

April 06, 2026

Prince Harry, 41, Sparked Buzz Among Royal Netizens by Reportedly Making a Heartfelt Private Gesture for Queen Elizabeth II's Landmark 100th Birthday – Photos

April 24, 2026

David Haye, 45, and Adam Thomas, 37, Clashed on 'I'm a Celebrity' Before Haye's Eviction – Video That Ignited Buzz

April 21, 2026

Former TV Host Reveals One Thing Trump Did to All His Wives

June 03, 2026

She Got Married with Her Late Dad's Best Friend at Her Side — Guess Who She Is

May 14, 2026

'EastEnders' Debbie Arnold Reveals She's Found Love Again at 70 with a Man Nine Years Her Junior After Meeting at a Funeral

April 01, 2026

King Charles, 77, Stuns Royal Fans With Truly Beautiful and Touching Tribute on Queen Elizabeth II's 100th Birthday – Photos

April 22, 2026