Wife Makes Husband Choose between His Two Daughters

Frustrated by her husband's unwavering affection for his daughter from a prior marriage, a determined wife was poised to take drastic measures in a bid to shift his focus towards their daughter. She challenged him to prove his devotion by choosing their daughter over his firstborn. Keep reading to discover what happened next.

On February 3, 2022, an anonymous female contributor sought solace in the widely acclaimed "AITA" subreddit, unveiling her captivating tale to the online community. She had harbored hopes that her story wouldn't come across as chaotic, given the intense emotions that had consumed her.

A matrimonial bond of 21 years had once tied her and her husband together. He had previously parted ways with his pregnant spouse to be with her, although he had still retained the freedom to see his daughter, Kristen, whenever he pleased. Subsequently, their union brought forth their daughter, Sasha.

A Complex Family Dynamic

However, the couple's relationship hit a rocky patch, marked by her husband's infidelity, leading to a temporary separation. During that period, the woman took a firm stance, prohibiting him from visiting their daughter. Regrettably, this decision deprived her husband of witnessing Sasha's formative years, a fact she believed had a lasting impact.

She sought guidance and understanding from the Reddit community to alleviate her inner turmoil.

Her husband exhibited a stark contrast in his treatment of Kristen, 21, and Sasha, 18. "Kristen is his number one thing, he comes running if she calls him and he can just drop everything if she asks," explained the distraught wife. She had noticed her husband's willingness to drop everything for Kristen while Sasha seemed to exist on the periphery. Conversations invariably revolved around Kristen, leaving Sasha feeling neglected and hurt.

In her heart, the original poster was convinced that Kristen bore a deep-seated resentment towards her for being the reason behind her parents' separation. Kristen's actions had consistently pushed her buttons, with frequent phone calls to her husband, even during late hours when he was with her.

Moreover, Kristen had manipulated her father into spending a week each month at her apartment, leaving little time for Sasha, who shared a household with him. "He never spends as much time with Sasha and we live together. It's a victory if I manage to get us to watch a movie together," revealed OP.

But that wasn't all. The woman was dumbfounded when she discovered that her husband had bequeathed everything to Kristen in his will, including an apartment and his cherished WW2 collection. In stark contrast, Sasha had been allotted a meager room in an ancient hostel building.

The Cat Conundrum

Then came another issue: Kristen, already the owner of three feline companions, had brought yet another cat into her father's flat, claiming it had been abandoned and in need of shelter. OP firmly believed that Kristen's actions were a deliberate ploy to tether her husband to his second residence, further distancing him from Sasha and herself.

Moreover, the responsibility of caring for the cat compelled her spouse to spend more time away from home. Kristen was said to have cunningly orchestrated the situation, fully aware of its implications.

Not knowing what else to do, the anonymous teller confronted her husband, insisting he re-home the cat to avert a brewing conflict. His response was to consult Kristen, who accused him of betraying the innocent animal, subsequently cutting off communication with him.

OP watched as her husband spent a whole night penning apologies to placate his eldest daughter. Additionally, he vehemently declared his refusal to part with the cat despite having shown absolutely no initial desire to care for it. Thus, looking after the cat became yet another barrier preventing OP's husband from being with his family.

Making Her Husband Choose

When the poster's frustration reached its peak, she couldn't help but issue an ultimatum: making her husband choose between Kristen and Sasha. Balancing two relationships seemed highly unsustainable, and if he genuinely cared for Sasha, he needed to prove it by picking her at least once.

Several weeks elapsed since their confrontation, and OP's husband was yet to provide an answer. Meanwhile, she grappled with guilt, anger, and frustration. She recognized his love for Kristen but held onto the hope that the looming threat of losing Sasha's presence in his life would compel him to identify the needs of his other daughter.

OP concluded her post with one significant question: "So AITA for wanting my husband to focus on our daughter for a change instead of constantly running around his first daughter?" She sought guidance and understanding from the Reddit community to alleviate her inner turmoil.

What Do Redditors Think?

What do you think about this story? Click here to read another story where children showed up at their dad's funeral expecting an inheritance, only to learn that a stranger had inherited everything.