My father was abusive to my mother, now he is is frail, very frail. Should I feel guilty he is alone?

Manuela Cardiga
Aug 20, 2018
11:01 P.M.

The following letter has been edited for clarity and coherence.


Dear AmoMama,

My father is a very, very difficult man. He was abusive to my mother and started on my older brother when my brother started becoming an adolescent.

My mother would not stand for the abuse of her children so she took her 3 children away from him when I was 14.

I remember my childhood. I remember all the bad times and the very few good times as a family. So, my father lived his own life, remarried, divorced, had girlfriends did what he did.

My mom raised her 3 kids, never complained and gave us all the love we needed. Now my father is frail, very frail. My brothers want nothing to do with him and I feel really bad that he is alone.

He is miserable and no matter what there is no pleasing him. He lives 7 hours away by car, so a quick pop-in is impossible. Should I feel guilty he is alone? That he has no one? What is my duty as a daughter? I am 51, I have a family of my own. I am so torn!!


Dear Subscriber,

Remember that old saying? "As you sow, so shall you reap."


Sadly you father is now reaping the fruits of a lifetime of mistreating and neglecting his family. He chose to live as he did, and you have no reason to feel guilty for his situation.

You are not responsible for his actions and his choices, and that is what has brought him to this place in his life.

Your brothers have already shown they will not get involved, and your first duty is to your family, your husband, and your children. It is understandable and commendable that you feel empathy for his pain, but he is not your responsibility.

Contact the relevant authorities in the town he is living in, and find out if there are any programmes for assisted living he could apply for. That would be an act of kindness and fulfill your filial duty.

Be strong, be happy, be yourself.

Do you agree with our advice? What do you think this subscriber could do to solve her problem?

If you need help or advice, reach out to us, and thousands of women just like you who are struggling with the difficulties of life. You are not alone, we are here for you, and we listen; so write to us anonymously using this form.

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

Daughter Left Her Dad with Nothing After Her Granny's Death for a Good Reason — Story of the Day

February 09, 2024

‘Dad?’ Boy Finds His Soldier Father Sleeping on Street, ‘Who Are You?’ Man Responds – Story of the Day

April 10, 2024

I’m 51 and I Fell in Love with My Best Friend’s 33-Year-Old Son — My Story

March 02, 2024

Lonely Man Wakes up to the Doorbell Ringing, Hears Weak Voice Calling upon Him, ‘Dad, Help!’ — Story of the Day

April 25, 2024

Man Mocks Boy Reading Aloud on Plane, Begs Pardon by the End of the Flight — Story of the Day

March 22, 2024

Man Leaves His Bride on Their Wedding Day, Here Is Why – Subscriber Story

May 10, 2024

Elderly Mom Asks Son to Visit, He Does 2 Years Later and Finds a Gravesite Instead of Her Home — Story of the Day

February 01, 2024

Granddaughter Reads Old Diary to Her Grandma With Alzheimer's and Learns a Secret She Should Never Have Known – Story of the Day

February 13, 2024

Orphan Boy Waits for Mom at Bus Stop until a Woman Gets off the Bus and Shelters Him – Story of the Day

February 22, 2024

Single Dad Struggles Raising Triplets, One Day Finds Out They Aren’t His — Story of the Day

May 02, 2024

Woman Captures Homeless People for 10 Years and Recognizes Lost Dad in One of the Photos — Story of the Day

April 18, 2024

Man Insults Driver during Business Trip until He Finds out Who He Really Is — Story of the Day

April 11, 2024

Wealthy Heir Humiliates Beggar Outside Luxury Hotel, Finds His Bank Account Drained Next Morning – Story of the Day

March 09, 2024

Father Left Me with a Foster Family Because I Reminded Him of My Mom – Story of the Day

March 25, 2024