Indiana couple sues school blaming his suspension for their son's suicide 2 years ago

Nov 30, 2018
03:34 A.M.

A couple from Indiana file lawsuit against a high school for their disciplinary action taken on their son, which allegedly led to his suicide almost two years ago.


17-year-old Patrick McCalley died on October 6, 2016, from a self-inflicted gunshot wound after he was handed an in-house suspension at Carmel High School for his racially inappropriate Snapchat messages that he sent to another student.

Now his parents, Chris and Marilyn, have sued the high school alleging that their son underwent an “extreme and excessive psychological distress” while being questioned by an assistant principal at the school.

Patrick was isolated in a closed room while being interrogated by Toby Steele, the assistant principal, and Carmel Police Officer Phil Hobson.


Follow us on Twitter to learn more.

The lawsuit filed at Hamilton County states that in the aftermath of the questioning, the student wrote a “self-incriminating statement” under the penalty of perjury. He was also told that he was being suspended from school.

His parents have claimed that Patrick was an outstanding student at the school, where he excelled as the member of the marching band, jazz band, and concert band. He had no previous records of indiscipline.


On the day he was handed suspension, he woke up a “happy, well-adjusted boy” who had just received an email correspondence from a representative of the United States Air Force, where he was considering his future.

The parents showed their outrage at the fact that following a closed questioning session with Steele, their son had decided that he no longer wanted to live.

The lawsuit named Carmel Clay School Corporation, Carmel High School, the city of Carmel, former district superintendent Nicholas Wahl, and questioners Steele and Hobson as defendants.

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar

The parents have sought damages for the “loss of love and companionship” of Patrick as well as medical, burial, and legal expenses related to his demise.

Meanwhile, the district officials responded to IndyStar with a statement denying the allegations. Their statement claimed that the facts of the incident are different from what is transcribed in the lawsuit.

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar


At the same time, the bereaved parents stressed the fact that they want to turn their tragedy into a lesson for other parents so that they won’t have to suffer a similar fate.

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar

Source: Facebook/IndianapolisStar

They have called for a policy requiring that a parent or a counselor be present during such a stressful meeting between students and school administrators.

The incident has further raised the larger question as to how should school administration work to discipline their students.

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

‘Grinch Girl’ Started Working at 2, Lived ‘A Very Adult Life’ in Her Teens & Turned to Drugs after Producer Died

November 14, 2023

Teachers Isolated Schoolboy for His 'Too Extreme' Haircut & Gave Him Week to Get Rid of It

October 31, 2023

My Wife Demands That I Pay a Bill of $700+ for Her and Her Friends

November 06, 2023

What Susan Lucci Would Look like at 77 If She Didn’t Use Botox – Photo via AI

January 31, 2024

People Share Best Loopholes That They Exploited For Years

December 26, 2023

Pierce Brosnan's Son Broke His Back & Learned How to Walk Again – He Is Now a Dad of 2 with Wife of 10 Years

January 17, 2024

Student Shouts Out Loud When She Sees Her Teacher for the First Time: 'My Dad Has a Picture of You' – Story of the Day

February 16, 2024

Autumn Rosalia Busey Is Her Parents' 'Destiny' – What We Know of Gary Busey's Granddaughter

October 30, 2023

Old School Cleaner Shamed by Children Turns Out to Be a Rich Man with Huge Inheritance — Story of the Day

February 26, 2024

‘Dirty Dancing’ Stars Jennifer Grey and Patrick Swayze Were Like ‘Oil and Water’ — How Their Kids Would Have Looked via AI

November 28, 2023

Texas Surgeon & His 2 Young Children Found Dead: 'The Tragedy That This Family Has Endured Is Unimaginable'

January 17, 2024

People Share Best Loopholes That They Exploited For Years

December 29, 2023

Kayna Whitworth: A Successful TV Journalist and a Doting Mother of Two Sons

November 23, 2023

Jon Bon Jovi Almost Lost His Only Daughter – Glimpse into Tragic Day He Got ‘The Worst Phone Call Ever’

February 08, 2024