logo
Getty Images
Getty Images

Simon Cowell Brings Charlotte Summers to Tears after Lamenting 'Terrible' Song Choice at AGT

Bettina Dizon
Aug 23, 2019
12:00 A.M.

Charlotte Summers, 13, cried on stage after Simon Cowell harshly criticized her choice of song at “America’s Got Talent’s” quarterfinals.

Advertisement

Yet another contestant of a competition series was left hurt by a blunt comment of Simon Cowell. 13-year-old Charlotte Summers was left in tears after giving her all at the “America’s Got Talent” second night of the quarter-finals.

"A TERRIBLE SONG CHOICE"

Summers performed an outstanding cover of Shirley Bassey’s “Diamonds Are Forever,” which became a hit after being used in the James Bond film. However, the judges didn’t think that her song of choice was fit for her personality.

“That was a terrible, terrible, terrible song choice,” Cowell said.

Advertisement

The crowd immediately booed at the judge’s criticism, while tears started running down Summers’ face. However, Cowell had more to say than a mere critique of the song. He added:

“I’m really praying that the audience dismisses the song choice, that wasn’t your fault, remembers what a great person you are, what a great singer you are, and how much better we can advise you if you make it through to the next round.”

The Spanish teen previously performed a powerful rendition of Lesley Gore’s “You Don’t Own Me,” which earned her praises from all the judges including guest judge Jay Leno, who admitted to being “blown away” by the singer.

Advertisement

EMOTIONAL COMMENTS

Social media flooded with heartfelt comments of people sharing their sentiments over the 13-year-old’s performance and the comments she received. Many “felt bad” as well but commended Summers for her brave heart.

Advertisement

“I can’t help but feel bad for a child when they cry on these shows (I’m a person, too), but whoever handed Charlotte that song should be fired,” one comment read.

HER PREVIOUS PERFORMANCE

The Spanish teen previously performed a powerful rendition of Lesley Gore’s “You Don’t Own Me,” which earned her praises from all the judges including guest judge Jay Leno, who admitted to being “blown away” by the singer.

Cowell, at that time, had no harsh words to say for Summers, even complimenting her “real rawness,” and discreetly saying she has a strong fighting chance to win the competition against Cenicio Bryant, Mackenzie, and the Voices of Service.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts
Tim McGraw and wife singer Faith Hill | Source: Getty Images

Tim McGraw's Daughter Audrey Sings Faith Hill's Song at Jones Beach and Fans Say She's 'Her Mom's Twin' — Video

July 27, 2026

Carly Simon | Source: Getty Images

Carly Simon, 83, Opens up with a Personal Health Confession — And Photos of Her Longtime Home Reveal How She's Really Been Living

July 28, 2026

Kai Trump | Source: Getty Images

Kai Trump, 19, Turns Heads in a Gold Gown at the 2026 ESPY Awards — and Her Walk Has Everyone Talking

July 17, 2026

Wiz Khalifa and Peachy Wimbush-Polk | Source: Getty Images

From 10-Person Crowds to Stardom: The Inspiring Story of Wiz Khalifa's Growth Mindset and the Maternal Belief That Fueled It

July 02, 2026

Jorge Messi | Source: Getty Images

Jorge Messi, the Man Behind Lionel's Rise to Greatness, Dies at 68 in His Hometown in Argentina

August 09, 2026

James Haven and Angelina Jolie | Source: Getty Images

Angelina Jolie's Brother Comes Out as Gay after Years Away from the Spotlight — His Story & Photos

August 07, 2026

Katie Couric | Source: Getty Images

Katie Couric's Daughters Ellie and Carrie: What Is Known About Them and Their Family – Details

July 10, 2026

Kelly Clarkson | Adam Rubin | Source: Getty Images

Brooklyn Store Owner Extends an Olive Branch to Kelly Clarkson After Their Public Spat Over a Mechanical Bird

October 17, 2026

Shania Twain | Source: YouTube/Etalk

Shania Twain Reveals Why She Skipped Taylor Swift's Wedding – And the Reason Has Sparked Divided Reactions Online

July 16, 2026

Sophia Bush and Chad Michael Murray | Source: Getty Images

Sophia Bush Revealed She Befriended Women Her Ex-Husband Chad Michael Murray Allegedly Cheated on Her With

October 22, 2026

Lucky Blue and Nara Smith | Source: Getty Images

Influencer Nara Smith Shares the Reason She Has Been Posting Less — and the Family News She and Lucky Blue Have Been Keeping Private

July 02, 2026