Landlord from Texas Is Accused of Killing a Woman in 2006 Who Rented an Apartment from Him

Lois Oladejo
May 19, 2021
03:20 A.M.
A former landlord in Llano County has been indicted for the death of his tenant, Holly Simmons, whose body was found in a lake in 2009, three years after her death in 2006.

Jimmy Wolfenbarger, a landlord from Llano County, has been arraigned on a one-count murder charge for the murder of Holly Simmons, 46, who died in November 2006.

Simmons was reported missing by her 17-year-old daughter on November 28, 2006. She noted that the last time she ever saw her mother was when she took her to the school bus.

Photo of a police car parked on the street | Photo: Pexels

Photo of a police car parked on the street | Photo: Pexels

Llano County Sheriff's Office and the Texas Rangers investigated for years without having a breakthrough. Following her disappearance, the victim's house was completely searched for information, and neighbors were questioned.

On July 7, 2009, a recreational diver found a boat immersed at the bottom of Inks lake. Simmons' body was found at the bottom of the boat. She had a concrete bag attached to her body.

Photo of a police crime scene tape | Photo: Pexels

Photo of a police crime scene tape | Photo: Pexels

In 2016, the Texas Rangers Unsolved Crimes Investigation Program reviewed the case largely. It then handed it over to a Texas Ranger to re-investigate with Llano County Sheriff's Office after years of being hampered.

After five years of investigating, Wolfenbarger was named a suspect. The 57-year-old landlord who lived in an RV park often had arguments with Simmons, scrutinizing one of her two daughters.

A resident of Antioch was shot during a dispute between the landlord and tenant.


Wolfenbarger was jailed in the Lubbock County detention center on May 12, 2021, after turning himself in, with the bail set at $2million. He has been released after posting bond.

It was revealed after an autopsy that the cause of death was strangulation. Simmons' siblings spoke to KXAN and revealed that they were relieved after waiting 15 years for the case to be solved and expressed displeasure.

Simmons' brother Paul Wishman said Wolfenbarger should be behind bars and hoped that he would not be allowed to get away for his crime.


He further said they have a good case and hoped that justice would be served for his late sister, her kids, grandkids, and the rest of the family.

This is not the first landlord case experienced recently, as a resident of Antioch was shot during a dispute between the landlord and tenant.

The resident, identified as Cosmo Baldazo, was found lying on his front lawn with gunshot wounds after a confrontation with his landlord. The case is currently under investigation by the police.

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

Girl Wondered How Mom Could Leave Her at a Year Old – 40 Years Later, a Police Discovery Solved Mom’s Disappearance

December 15, 2023

Two Little Sisters Go Missing after Last Seen in Pajamas in Their Home at 11 p.m.

January 26, 2024

Two Little Boys Die in Tragic Incident after Staying Home Due to School Cancellations amid Frigid Weather

January 24, 2024

Dad, Who Cried on Camera over Late 5-Year-Old Son, Arrested for His Murder 34 Years Later – Details

January 15, 2024

Husband Notices 'Odd Taste' in Drinks & Food His Wife Gives Him, Installs Surveillance Camera at Home

January 19, 2024

My Partner Learned I Rent Out the House My Dad Gifted Me & Demands 50 Percent of the Money

May 04, 2024

Texas Surgeon & His 2 Young Children Found Dead: 'The Tragedy That This Family Has Endured Is Unimaginable'

January 17, 2024

10-Month-Old Baby Found Dead near Still-Living Father after 36-Hour Search

December 05, 2023

Woman Fails to End Call, Husband Accidentally Overhears Her Conversation – Story of the Day

April 05, 2024

Where Is Gypsy Rose Blanchard's Ex-boyfriend, Her Accomplice in Matricide, upon Her Regaining Freedom

January 09, 2024

Peter Falk's Daughter Was Banned from Dad's Funeral - Years Later She Fought for the Rights of Other Families

January 16, 2024

Girl, 1, Dies after Being Left with Dad's Girlfriend While He Goes to Store: 'Details of This Case Are Heartbreaking'

January 17, 2024

Who Is Gypsy Rose Blanchard, Who Was Forced to Fake Illness in Wheelchair & Was Involved in Mother's Passing?

December 29, 2023

Jeffrey Marty Is Stacey Dash’s Ex-husband Who Claims He Was Hypnotized into Marrying Her

January 22, 2024