Man Goes on a Date with Woman He Met on Dating Site and Meets Child He Never Knew about Instead – Story of the Day

Roshanak Hannani
Feb 23, 2022
11:00 P.M.

Brian dated many girls in his 20s but proposed to only one, Melanie. However, they broke things off due to his cheating and moved on. Years later, he wanted to find someone to spend the rest of his life with and registered on a dating site. But the woman he met online was nothing like he expected.


“Ok, done,” Brian said to himself as he right-clicked on the website and finished setting up his dating profile. He was in his 50s and felt like he was ready to settle down after not dating anyone seriously for most of his life. That’s when Melanie entered his thoughts.

She was a freshman when he was a senior in college in New York. They dated for a long time, and he eventually proposed when she entered her senior year. But she had no idea that Brian was cheating on her with several women the entire time. He couldn’t stop himself. It was like he was afraid of commitment but still wanted to be with Melanie.

Brian sat at the coffee shop and waited. | Source: Shutterstock

Brian sat at the coffee shop and waited. | Source: Shutterstock

Unfortunately, she discovered the truth of his affairs when one of Brian’s many one-night stands revealed the truth. She called off the wedding and disappeared from his life.


Brian felt heartbroken, although he knew she was right. He wasn’t a good man. He wanted to get married but still led a single-man lifestyle. It would’ve never worked. This was best for everyone involved.

Brian continued his philandering life, although he was perfectly entitled because he never went steady with anyone else. He often thought of Melanie and how great she was. And now that he was in his 50s, he regretted cheating on her. He was an idiot, and perhaps he would have a companion if he had valued her properly.

“Yes, Brian. He’s your kid.

But it didn’t make sense to dwell on the past. He had to move on and try to find someone. That’s why he decided to create a profile on a dating website. It was the modern way of dating, and he was shooting his shot.

A man in his 30s sat down at the next table. | Source: Pexels

A man in his 30s sat down at the next table. | Source: Pexels


A few days later, he got a message from a woman named Stephanie. She was in her 30s and was looking for someone to get serious. Brian thought she might be his best shot, and her profile pictures were beautiful. After several weeks of messaging, they agreed to meet at the local Starbucks, and Brian was excited.

He arrived at the coffee shop and noticed that it was pretty empty, so he ordered something and sat down to wait for Stephanie. Suddenly, a man in his 30s entered, ordered something, and sat down on the table next to them. For some reason, Brian kept staring at him. There was something familiar about his face, but he couldn’t quite place it.

Then, she walked in. It wasn’t Stephanie. It was Melanie. After 30 years of no communication, she was finally there in front of him. She sat down at the table with the young man, and they both turned to look at Brian. He felt something ominous crawl up his spine and kept staring between them.

“Hello Brian,” Melanie finally spoke up.

“Melanie? What are you doing here?” he asked, stunned by this whole thing.

Melanie introduced her son. | Source: Pexels

Melanie introduced her son. | Source: Pexels


She didn’t answer his question. “This is my son, Ryan. Or you might know him best as Stephanie. I’ll let him explain everything,” Melanie gestured toward the young man in front of her, and he turned toward Brian.

“Hello,” Brian uttered, confusion evident on his face.

“Hello. As she said, I’m Ryan. And I guess you’re my father, the cheater,” the young man began, and Brian felt like a blow had been dealt against his chest. This encounter was the past coming back to haunt him. Melanie must have been pregnant when they ended their relationship, and he had missed his son’s entire life.

“I am?” Brian still asked and looked at Melanie.

“Yes, Brian. He’s your kid. Of course, I never told you about my pregnancy, but I told him all about you. He still wanted to find you, and that’s why we’re here,” Melanie explained.

“I don’t understand. So, you catfished me as Stephanie? Why?” Brian wondered.

Brian admitted that he was horrible to many women. | Source: Pexels

Brian admitted that he was horrible to many women. | Source: Pexels


“Honestly, I had no idea where to start finding you outside of regular social media. But that would’ve been too easy. I wanted to see if you were still dating around and a dating website seemed like the best choice. I signed up and just like that you appeared. Are you married? Did you want to cheat on your wife with Stephanie?” Ryan taunted.

“Stop, Ryan. That’s enough cruelty. I only agreed to this because you have been dying to meet your father for years. Just talk to him,” Melanie scolded. He might be mad that he never had a father in his life and about everything he knew from his mother, but he didn’t have to speak to him like that.

But Brian interjected. “I actually understand why he’s so angry. I’ve been reflecting a lot lately, and I did you wrong, Melanie. I did tons of women wrong in my life. I can’t make up for it. I can only do better now. And I want to know you if you allow it, Ryan.”

He wanted to make up for his past. | Source: Pexels

He wanted to make up for his past. | Source: Pexels


Ryan nodded. “I understand that you regret things now. And I’m the one who reached out to you. I’m sorry about catfishing you and for how I spoke just now. But I don’t know if I can forgive you just like that. Especially because Mom went through so much to raise me on her own.”

“What can I do?” Brian begged.

“Just try to do better and be honest about your intentions,” Melanie chimed in. “Honesty is the basis of all relationships.”

“Ok. I can do that. I’ve grown up. I was honestly on the dating website because I wanted to find someone to settle down with but meeting you two is so much better. I can never erase the past, but we can start over and try to be a family,” Brian said, hoping his words sounded as sincere as he felt.

Melanie nodded at him, and Ryan reluctantly did so too. They started talking on the phone often, and they met for coffee several times each week. Melanie was not at those meetings, but Brian saw her every once in a while. Eventually, Brian earned a place in his son’s heart, even if it wasn’t exactly as a father figure.

Brian was there for his grandchildren. | Source: Pexels

Brian was there for his grandchildren. | Source: Pexels


But despite his efforts, he never earned a similar spot with Melanie. She was cordial to him, especially at gatherings for Ryan, but she didn’t want anything to do with him. And Brian had to respect that. He signed off the website and stopped looking for women, choosing to focus on his son, who got married and had kids.

Luckily, he was there for his grandchildren, and he couldn’t have been gladder that Ryan gave him a second chance.

What can we learn from this story?

  • Always be honest about your intentions. Brian proposed to Melanie despite being afraid of commitment and breaking her heart.
  • Don’t do anything you might regret in the future. Brian was a philanderer in his youth and regretted it eventually. Learn from his mistakes and reflect on your life.

Share this story with your friends. It might brighten their day and inspire them.

If you enjoyed this story, you might like this one about a homeless man who discovered a girl’s diary.

This account is inspired by our reader’s story and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.  

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

Mom Can't Wait to Meet Her Son's Girlfriend, Stunned When He Brings a Woman the Same Age as Her – Story of the Day

October 31, 2023

Dog Barks at Coffin during Funeral, Suspicious Son Opens It and Discovers It Empty – Story of the Day

October 12, 2023

‘Total Garbage,’ Music Teacher Mocks Immigrant Student’s Song, Hears It on Radio Later – Story of the Day

October 26, 2023

Stewardess Breaks Rules and Helps Guy Visit Dying Mom ASAP, He Rewards Her Fully – Story of the Day

September 25, 2023

Boy Finds Old Tube in Late Granny's Attic, History Teacher Opens It and Gasps – Story of the Day

October 18, 2023

Gender Reveal Party Goes Awry as Husband Declares to Pregnant Wife He's Sterile – Story of the Day

November 07, 2023

Daughter Stolen at Birth Reunites with Dad 34 Years Later, Learns He’s in Huge Trouble – Story of the Day

September 29, 2023

I Was Sure That My Husband’s Daughter Lived with Us until I Found Them in Bed Together – Story of the Day

October 20, 2023

Сrying Girl in Shabby Clothes Bursts into Wedding and Goes into Labor Right at Groom's Feet – Story of the Day

October 12, 2023

Granddad Forbids Anyone to Touch His Old Mattress, Girl Finds Stash There after His Death – Story of the Day

October 04, 2023

Suspicious Wife Got into a Taxi and Offered Whatever Price for Following the Car – Story of the Day

October 30, 2023

Man Is Stunned Seeing His Wife at the Altar with Another Man: ‘But You Died Last Year!’ – Story of the Day

September 22, 2023

Woman Is Sure Her Husband Died until She Comes across His New Tinder Profile – Story of the Day

October 23, 2023

‘The Groom Is a Fraud! Here’s the Proof!’ Stranger Woman Interrupts Bride’s Vow — Story of the Day

August 04, 2023