My Husband Asked For Paternity Test after I Gave Birth – He Was 'Shocked' When He Read the Results

Upon the birth of their daughter, a woman experienced an unexpected response from her husband. Rather than celebrating the joyous occasion, he requested a paternity test, casting doubt on the baby's lineage. Faced with no alternative, she underwent the test, and the results proved to be eye-opening.

On December 20, 2023, an anonymous female contributor opened up about her experience in Reddit's "AITAH" forum. Having been married to her 28-year-old husband for two years, she detailed the recent birth of their daughter, which occurred just five weeks prior.

In an attempt to provide a comprehensive account without delving into superfluous details, the Original Poster, aged 27, revealed a noteworthy aspect of the situation. Their newborn daughter emerged into the world adorned with striking features—blonde hair and pale blue eyes.

What heightened the intrigue was the fact that both the Original Poster and her husband exhibited the more common traits of brown hair and brown eyes. This curious deviation prompted OP to seek advice and insights from the online community, as her husband's unexpected reaction had left her grappling with questions about the child's paternity.

A day before sharing her narrative online, OP and her husband received the paternity test results.

In response to this unexpected revelation, OP's husband exhibited a strong emotional reaction, expressing distress and refusing to entertain her explanation. Despite her attempts to clarify that infants often have lighter hair and eye colors that may darken with time, the husband remained unconvinced.

He escalated the situation by insisting on a paternity test, coupled with the ultimatum of divorce if she did not comply. Faced with this demand, OP reluctantly underwent the paternity test to address her husband's concerns.

The Shocking Results

Following the hospital discharge, OP and her daughter returned home, and her husband opted to spend the initial three weeks at his parents' residence to create some distance while she recovered. During this time, he informed his parents about the situation.

Subsequently, the mother-in-law contacted OP and conveyed a disturbing message. She asserted that if the paternity test disproved the husband's biological connection to the child, she would use her influence to ensure OP faced significant consequences in the impending divorce, vowing to see her "taken to the cleaners."

Navigating this challenging period, the woman found support and assistance from her sister, who became a pillar of strength, helping her care for the newborn amid the tumultuous circumstances.

A day before sharing her narrative online, OP and her husband received the paternity test results. "I was on the couch in the living room, so [my husband] sat next to me and we started to read the results," said OP. "They showed that he was the father and my husband had this shocked, kinda mortified look on his face with his eyes wide as he stared at it."

How Did OP React?

Unable to contain herself, OP couldn't resist uttering, "I told you so," and burst into laughter at her husband's stunned expression. This reaction snapped him out of his initial shock, and he became angered by her amusement. A heated argument ensued, characterized chiefly by his raised voice, until OP's sister intervened by coming downstairs, causing the husband to fall silent.

Following the confrontation, the husband retreated once again to his parents' house, citing the need to "clear his head." A few hours later, OP found herself on the receiving end of a scolding from her mother-in-law, who expressed disapproval for her laughter, deeming it as kicking her husband while he was down.

This sentiment was reiterated in a couple of nasty texts received the following morning. Seeking an outsider's perspective, OP couldn't help but wonder, "AITA for telling my husband "I told you so" and laughing at [him] when we got the paternity test results?"

What Do Redditors Think?

OP's narrative gained significant traction online, capturing the attention and responses of netizens from far and wide. A multitude of commenters rallied in support of OP, condemning her husband and mother-in-law for their disrespectful behavior.

"Crazy story, right? But here's an even more shocking one: a mother-in-law secretly did a DNA test on her daughter's baby and then told her son-in-law to get a divorce!

After moving into her in-laws' house, Redditor ThunderCunty thought she was surrounded by people who genuinely loved her. Well, maybe…but it wasn't until her mother-in-law decided to wreak havoc in her marriage by taking a secret paternity test on the woman's baby.

The mom posted her story on Reddit's "JUSTNOMIL" sub, where readers fumed over the incredible drama the mother-in-law sparked after the DNA test results arrived.

The Original Poster's (OP) mother-in-law, Edith, was generally a lovely person. Maybe that's what OP thought, especially after the mother-in-law (MIL) welcomed her into the family after OP eloped with her son.

Just then, her MIL chimed in and said that she knew OP had been cheating on her husband. She then told her son to divorce OP.

Edith offered to watch her granddaughter while OP and her husband worked. Even OP thought it was an amazing idea, but one unbelievable incident pushed her to put her baby in daycare and away from her mother-in-law.

As it turned out, OP's mother-in-law had decided that her granddaughter didn't look like her son. So, she headed for a paternity test on the child, and instead of testing the baby's father, she tested his adopted brother.

The woman was aware that the results would declare her son as not the child's father, and this was what she wanted. So, after the results came back, she called OP and her son to come home immediately.

The couple was at work but took off on the spot and rushed home. As soon as they arrived, OP's mother-in-law showed them a mail about the paternity test.

Puzzled about what was happening, OP's husband opened it and read it. Unsurprisingly, the results revealed that he was not the child's father, just as his mom had expected.

OP's husband was fuming and asked his mom what this was about. OP was stunned, and she couldn't decipher what was going on. Her MIL chimed in and said that she knew OP had been cheating on her husband. She then told her son to divorce OP.

A few minutes into the intense drama, the couple realized that OP's husband was never tested for his child's paternity, and he'd never signed for one. They immediately learned that the MIL tested their daughter with someone else, so the results came back negative.

Shortly after the incident, the couple headed to a paternity test center in town and took the test. When Edith was on her way to drop her granddaughter at her parents' house, OP and her husband told her that they had exciting news to share. They then showed the woman the results, and she turned red.

However, the mother-in-law stood her ground against OP and tried her best to manipulate her son into thinking OP had cheated on him. She claimed OP had messed up the test and even said she could've taken the test on the baby's biological father and swapped the results.

Edith then asserted that OP would've done anything to prove the child was her son's so that he wouldn't leave her. She reasoned that OP planned to stay in this marriage and claim his money and inheritance.

OP was crushed and fuming at the same time. She couldn't believe that her mother-in-law would come down to such a level to shame her and destroy her marriage. OP then turned to Reddit to unleash her emotional baggage.

After OP publicized the incident online, several people condemned the mother-in-law and suggested OP permanently cut ties with her. Redditor elysians stated:

"Uhhhh, that level of disrespect and subterfuge is grounds for going no-contact permanently."

Some, like user ThatOneChic25, felt it was time to say goodbye to Edith. "Please tell me your husband has decided to go no contact with the woman who attempted to destroy his family," the person said, adding:

"If not, then at least never let her have any alone time with your child(ren). If she is willing to tell your husband, he is not the father. Just imagine what she may tell your daughter and any other future children if she was alone with them."

In the end, OP stated that she never cheated on her husband and would never think of doing that. "I love him, and he's the father of our daughter," she proclaimed.

She hoped her mother-in-law would find a new hobby and not plot ways to destroy her marriage again. "We aren't taking it anymore," OP concluded. However, only time will tell if OP's mother-in-law changed her attitude and regretted her mistake.

Other Online Users' Comments on the Matter

Redditors had more comments about the issue. They advised the OP and her husband about what they could do and shared these opinions:

If you liked reading this story, here's one about how a mom of triplets refused to give a dime from her inheritance to her husband after he did the same earlier.