College Sweethearts Luke Reimer and Mary Mich Found Deceased in a Car Behind Campus Dorm — Details

A loving young couple's romance ended in unspeakable tragedy, just months after celebrating their first anniversary.

Two Franciscan University of Steubenville students were found dead inside a vehicle on campus. Luke Reimer, 20, from Indian Shores, Florida, and Mary Mich, 20, of Downingtown, Pennsylvania, were discovered on Monday, January 19, 2025, in the rear parking lot of St. Agnes Residence Hall. Authorities responded shortly after 12:30 p.m.

Officers were dispatched to 1505 University Blvd. for a welfare check on two individuals seen in a parked car. When they arrived, both Reimer and Mich had already passed. The Steubenville Police Department stated there were no signs of foul play or any indication of drug use.

Cause of Death Confirmed

Toxicology results from the Jefferson County Coroner's Office revealed that both students died of carbon monoxide poisoning. The department confirmed the deaths were ruled accidental, citing a problem with the vehicle's exhaust.

In a letter to the campus community on the same day, Franciscan University President Father Dave Pivonka addressed the devastating news.

"Luke and Mary were found inside a motor vehicle shortly after noon today in the parking lot of St. Agnes Residence Hall," he wrote. "The Steubenville Police Department is investigating. At this time, early indicators suggest this was a tragic accident related to a potential vehicle exhaust or engine malfunction."

He continued, "This news brings profound sorrow to our entire Franciscan University community. We grieve the loss of two young lives, and our hearts ache for their families, friends, classmates, professors, and all who knew and loved them."

Campus Events Canceled

All scheduled events for that evening were canceled as the campus reeled from the loss. Instead, the university held a Holy Hour and Rosary at 7 p.m. in Christ the King Chapel.

The intention was "to place Luke and Mary into the loving hands of our Lord," Father Pivonka shared. Support services were also made available in residence halls and at the J. C. Williams Center.

A Public Declaration of Love

Just months before the tragedy, the couple had celebrated their first anniversary. On November 1, 2025, Reimer shared a series of photos on Instagram with the caption, "One year with the most beautiful woman! I love you ❤️."

The two were widely seen together on campus. Social media posts show Reimer in his lacrosse uniform during games and with teammates, friends, and Mich. He was a member of the university's lacrosse team.

A Father Speaks Through Grief

On January 20, the university posted a public tribute to the students on Facebook. "Eternal rest grant unto them O Lord and let perpetual light shine upon them," the post read. "Luke and Mary passed away on January 19, in what early indicators suggest was a tragic accident related to a potential vehicle exhaust or engine malfunction."

One comment stood out. Reimer's father left a raw and emotional message that captured the depth of his heartbreak.

"I miss my son more than I could ever say. I am so proud of him. Why would God allow this?" he questioned. "He was so happy and so much he was going to accomplish. My world has collapsed."

Students Encouraged to Seek Support

Father Pivonka urged students to lean on each other and seek help if needed. "In moments such as this, it is especially important that we care for one another," he stated.

Counselors, friars, faculty, and staff were made available for students struggling with the news. Parents were directed to contact Kim King, vice president of Student Life, with questions.

As of January 22, 2026, the Steubenville Police Department has not issued further updates. The incident remains classified as non-suspicious.