Former GMA3 Hosts TJ Holmes & Amy Robach's Ex-Spouses Spotted in PDA-Filled Photos, Dividing Fans

Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue seem to still be in love after a recent public appearance. Their lives took a dramatic turn in 2022, leaving them both devastated.

On June 10, 2024, attorney Marilee Fiebig and actor Andrew Shue were seen in New York City, engaging in public displays of affection. The couple, who came together after experiencing heartbreak, appear to be going strong.

Page Six shared photos on Instagram showing the pair hugging and kissing before parting ways. The images sparked a variety of reactions from followers, who had mixed feelings about their affection and relationship.

Reactions to the Instagram post were diverse. One user commented, "Swapping spouses? Now that's definitely weird." Another added, "Awkward and no chemistry." Despite these critical views, many expressed support for the couple. One person wrote, "Hey, it’s all good. Hopefully, they stay together."

Supporters continued with encouraging messages. "Good for them! I'm glad they got together and are doing well," said one. A second shared, "If anyone understood what each was going through, it was each other. I truly hope they last," while a third echoed, "I love their story! Worked in their favor. I'm rooting for them."

Others, however, remained skeptical."That's so weird but ok, long as they are happy," one individual noted. Some also pointed out the unique situation, suggesting, "So, they basically swapped partners. We need a series based on this love story." Another remarked, "If Revenge was maybe a picture!"

Fiebig and Shue, who found solace in each other after their respective marriages ended, have been dating for a while. They were first seen together in 2023, following reports of their developing relationship.

The paparazzi captured the couple packing two cats into Shue's Jeep before leaving for a weekend getaway. They appeared relaxed and content, dressed casually in jeans, hoodies, and sneakers.

Their relationship reportedly began about six months prior to the sighting. They allegedly bonded over the public dissolution of their marriages after the affair between Holmes and Robach was exposed in November 2022.

An insider at the time stated that Holmes and Robach were "two consenting adults who were each separated" from their spouses. The source said the pair ended things between their respective partners within weeks of each other, adding that their romance did not begin before that.

Meanwhile, another insider divulged that Robach had been dealing with heartache and Holmes was there to help and show her support. They shared that their connection has grown beyond the initial heartbreak, "It turned into something else, and they're connected over their values. It's bigger than the affair now."

Sources claim that Fiebig and Shue's relationship is serious and grounded in shared values. While Robach and Holmes have also moved on with their relationship, both couples seem to have found new paths. "They're not heartbroken and sad... everyone has moved on," another source confirmed.

Fiebig finalized her divorce from Holmes in October 2023. This came after she publicly spoke out about the affair through a statement via her lawyer, slamming Holmes's "lack of discretion, respect and sensitivity."

Holmes and Fiebig agreed to the terms of their divorce, with the New York County Supreme Court processing their dissolution. The settlement came ten months after Fiebig filed for divorce.

She and Holmes first crossed paths in 2009 and tied the knot in March 2010. Three years later, in January 2013, Fiebig, and her now ex-husband, who has two children from his first marriage, welcomed a daughter named Sabine.

Meanwhile, Shue and Robach settled their split in March 2023. The exes, although having no children together, had blended their families during their marriage.

In March 2023, Robach and Holmes were seen together, appearing happy following the settlement of her divorce with Shue. The former couple had been married for 12 years before they split.

They had privately worked out an agreement through mediation, which included custody of their dog, Brody. Shue was later seen picking up Brody from Robach's daughter at her Manhattan apartment.

"It's an awfully sad end to what was a great marriage. Andrew was so into her," a former friend of the exes expressed at the time. The pal added that it was better that Robach and Shue parted ways amicably through mediation instead of being embattled in a legal suit.

Robach and Shue's marriage ended publicly in August 2022 after Shue discovered his affair with Holmes. Despite the public nature of their separation, they kept details of their divorce private, resolving matters outside of court.

On the flip side, Holmes and Robach's romance began while covering the Queen's Platinum Jubilee in London in June 2022. Following reports of their affair, the two closed down their respective Instagram accounts.

However, in August 2023, Robach returned to the social media platform, sharing a black-and-white picture of two pairs of matching running shoes. In her caption for the post, the journalist mentioned the NY marathon.

The former ABC correspondent, who reportedly bonded with Holmes over their shared love for running, hinted they would be participating in the race and that they were training together.

Despite doubts about their future together, a friend confirmed, "T.J. and Amy are more in love than ever." The couple was officially removed from ABC's airwaves after an internal review of their affair.

Even after being shown the door because of their infidelity, Robach and Holmes still flaunted their romantic relationship in the public eye. They were often seen showing affection while strolling the streets of New York City and traveling together around the country and even overseas.

The intertwining lives of T.J. Holmes, Amy Robach, Shue, and Fiebig continue to captivate the public. While Holmes and Robach’s relationship faced scrutiny, Fiebig and Shue found solace in each other, creating a new chapter in their lives.