Amy Robach & TJ Holmes’ Exes Reportedly Now Dating & Fans Call It ‘Karma’

Amy Robach and TJ Holmes' exes, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, are reportedly dating. The pair bonded over their shared experiences with their exes, and fans are calling it karma.

After a controversial start to Amy Robach and TJ Holmes' relationship, it's been reported that their exes, Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue, are dating. Fiebig and Shue have been dating for six months after bonding over their shared experiences as Holmes and Robach's exes.

Robach and Holmes' affair stunned all those who knew them. It was a significant factor in the demise of their respective marriages and the heartbreak of their previous spouses.

However, new reports have made it clear that Shue and Fiebig are no longer heartbroken or sad. They've found comfort in one another and are bonding over shared values.

Fans couldn't help but share their thoughts about the budding romance. Several called it "karma," and that while it won't last, the exes are having fun given the traumatic situation they were once in.

"Call me karma baby," one said. "This is the best day ever! Karma’s a [expletive!]" someone added.

"I am so happy for them. I hope it works out," one supporter cheered on. "Happy for them, I bet they'll be together forever and the other two will be done in a couple years," another commented.

While many were happy that they all found a second shot at love, others felt for their children. They wondered how this new setup would affect the kids, as they're currently in the middle of it all.

"I just wonder what this does to the children," one user said. "I truly feel for their [c]hildren. They're [t]he ones who have been thrown in the middle of It all," another echoed.

Robach and Holmes made their relationship Instagram official in November 2023. This came a month after reports shared that Holmes and Fiebig reached a divorce settlement agreement after filing for divorce in December 2022 after 12 years of marriage.

After the "GMA" hosts made their relationship public, they revealed a new project they're working on together. They're hosting and executive producing a new podcast, which recently aired its first episode.