logo

Teacher fired over controversial slavery lesson plans $1B lawsuit for ‘reverse discrimination'

Mary Scott
Jan 14, 2019
07:56 P.M.

A New York City teacher fired for teaching a controversial lesson on slavery has revealed plans to sue the city for $1 billion, claiming she is being discriminated against for being white.

Advertisement
https://youtu.be/iXZWLzd5v6w

https://youtu.be/iXZWLzd5v6w

Patricia Cummings was fired in October after reports surfaced of her stepping on the backs of black students in her class.

According to Cummings, however, all she did was ask some of her students to volunteer to sit close to each other on the floor. She was teaching a lesson on slavery and wanted to depict how slaves sat on slave ships.

The allegations leveled against Cummings were vastly different. The teacher was accused of singling out black students, telling them to lie on the floor, and stepping on their backs while asking:

Advertisement

"How does it feel? See how it feels to be a slave."

https://youtu.be/iXZWLzd5v6w

https://youtu.be/iXZWLzd5v6w

Cummings' former workplace, the William W Niles School/MS 118 in the Bronx, has a student population that is predominantly black and Hispanic, and apparently, someone was not happy with whatever she demonstrated in class.

Initially, Cummings was reassigned by the city’s Department of Education, but when the incident began to receive more media coverage, she was fired.

Advertisement

Even though the department says otherwise, Cummings believes she is being discriminated against because she’s white.

"They're on the record for saying the reason I'm being terminated is because of my performance as an educator and the report," she said. "I've been rated effective by the Department of Education. I'm an effective teacher."

Advertisement

At a press conference, Cummings revealed that, beyond becoming unemployed, the backlash including death threats she’s been receiving, pose a danger to her life.

According to ABC 13, the 37-year-old now intends to sue “for discrimination, distress, and suffering.” Cummings is now planning to sue a range of defendants including the city Department of Education to Mayor Bill de Blasio and several media outlets.

Cummings also has the support of a black teacher who was in the class while she delivered her lesson and found it “appropriate.”

Advertisement

Her attorney, Thomas Liotti, told ABC 7:

“White teachers are sometimes typecast as racist and they’re not racist. So, it’s a case of reverse discrimination.”

"Ms. Cummings is a dedicated and competent teacher, who should never have been subjected to these false accusations, which have damaged her career and her reputation," he added.

Meanwhile, the Department of Education said in a statement:

"Ms. Cummings was terminated based on a thorough investigation and a review of her performance as an educator. We'll review the complaint."

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts
Kaylee Hottle | Source: Getty Images

Inside Kaylee Hottle's Final Years: Her School, Her Films, and the Red Carpet She Walked Before Her Passing

July 22, 2026

The Karolkiewicz Family | Source: Facebook/LisaJudii

'Suspicious' Fire Kills Beloved Teacher, Her Husband, and 6 Children in Michigan — Officers Say One Theory Is Being Investigated

July 27, 2026

Kaylee Hottle | Source: Getty Images

'Godzilla vs. Kong' Actress Kaylee Hottle Dies at 19 in Maryland Car Crash — Details Emerge About Who Was With Her

July 22, 2026

Kaylee Hottle | Source: Getty Images

Family Photos Offer a Glimpse Into Kaylee Hottle's Life as Her Mother Reacts to Her Death

July 22, 2026

Amanda and Kristopher Karolkiewicz | The Karolkiewicz children | Source: TikTok/@mandykarolk

What Happened Before a Michigan Family of Eight Died? A Timeline of the Tragedy

July 29, 2026

Fred Marsh and Hailey Lummus | Source: GoFundMe

Officer Fred Marsh, 24, Asked the Love of His Life a Life-Changing Question Hours Before His Fate Was Sealed on the Elk River

July 23, 2026

A yellow "Police Line Do Not Cross" barrier tape spans across an active investigation scene. | Source: Getty Images

Twin Falls In-N-Out Shooting Survivor Terry Dudley Was Between Taxi Rides When His Ordinary Afternoon Turned Into a Nightmare

August 03, 2026

Ashley Garibay | Source: Facebook/ashleygaribay

The In-N-Out Employee Killed in Idaho Has Been Identified — Her Family Reveals the Dream She Never Got to Fulfill

August 04, 2026

Adriana Coleman's children | Source: Facebook/adriana.simmons.180

What Started as a Flat Tire Ended in an Unimaginable Family Tragedy That Claimed Four Young Siblings and Their Grandmother

July 20, 2026

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift | Source: Instagram/taylorswift

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Wedding Had a Surprising Officiant, Long Vows, and a Document Everyone Had to Sign Away — Details

July 06, 2026

Taylor Swift | Source: Getty Images

Inside the Lavish Raffle Prizes and Gifts Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Gave Guests at Their Wedding – From Cartier to a Surprise in a Black Velvet Box

July 06, 2026