logo
Getty Images
Getty Images

Beyoncé and Jay-Z Sued by Jamaican Artist Dr L'Antoinette Stines Over Song 'Black Effect'

Kagweni Micheni
By Kagweni Micheni
Jun 22, 2020
04:30 P.M.

Jay Z and his wife Beyonce are facing some legal issues after Jamaican artist Dr L'Antoinette sued the couple over the song "Black Effect."

Advertisement

Jay Z and his wife Beyonce may be royalty when it comes to the music industry, but that does not mean they are immune to legal or copyright issues.

Recently Jamaican artist Dr. L'Antoinette Staines revealed that she had sued the couple for their song "Black Effect", where she is the lead voice.

Advertisement

During an interview with TMZ, Staines said that she had been shocked when she first heard the track as the famous couple had initially told her that her interview would only be used for promotional purposes.

Her lawsuits filed this week explained that she had been told to sign an "agreement" to participate and was not allowed to show the document to her brother who was an attorney. The suit said,

"To the shock, horror and chagrin of Dr Stines, the project featured the unauthorized exploitation of her vocals on a song known as "Black Effect." This discovery left Dr Stined feeling violated."

Advertisement

Dr. Stines had met the couple after supplying dancers for a promotional video for Jay-z and Beyonce's album and tour. However, her voice ended up being used in the first minute of the track.

The artist suit claimed that she had not been credited or paid for the role, leaving her feeling as though she had been "artistically raped."

The voice clip which is underscored by the music starts with her talking about how each type of love has a different shape.

Advertisement

During the song, Stines is asked to talk to about love and gives a poetic response describing the different types of love that exist.

The voice clip which is underscored by the music starts with her talking about how each type of love has a different shape, with her adding,

"But all of them is the same in the end: it's about sensitivity, it's about passion, it's about unconditional giving of self to another person."

Beyoncé at the Kobe Bryant Memorial Service on February 24, 2020, at the STAPLES Center in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Beyoncé at the Kobe Bryant Memorial Service on February 24, 2020, at the STAPLES Center in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Advertisement

In the lawsuit which is claiming copyright infringement as well as violating her right to publicity, the artist is seeking damages as well as a writing credit on the track.

The song appeared on the 2018 "Everything Is Love," album, with the lead single being the colossal hit "Apesh**t". The release of the collection by the Carters was also a surprise.

Representatives for Beyonce and Jay-Z have not yet commented on the situation. They have also not responded to the lawsuit in court.

Dr. Stines' vocals make up 19% of the song, with the album winning the "Best Urban Contemporary Album" at the 61st Annual Grammy Awards.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts

Martha Reeves, 85, Takes the Field at Women's Baseball League Opener to Sing the National Anthem — Video

August 04, 2026

What Would Shania Twain Look Like Without Cosmetic Procedures? AI Imagines a Different Future — Photos

July 29, 2026

Gabrielle Union and Dwyane Wade Turn Heads at Met Gala 2026 — Photos

May 05, 2026

Wiz Khalifa's Pittsburgh: Favorite Spots, Local Tips, and the Story Behind His Rise

June 19, 2026

Donald Trump Pays Over $5.6 Million to Author Who Sued Him

July 15, 2026

Tia Mowry Igniting Buzz Over Surprise Romance Reveal in Cabo — Photos

May 29, 2026

Celine Dion Shares Touching Memory About Peabo Bryson's Kindness During 'Beauty and the Beast' Recording

June 03, 2026

Madison Beer's NFL Star Fiancé Proposes with a Ring That Has a Surprising Connection to Taylor Swift's — Photos

July 30, 2026

Wiz Khalifa on How Independent Artists Are Competing Against Million-Dollar Budgets

July 01, 2026

Venus Williams Dazzles at 2026 Met Gala and Ignites Talk Over Appearance and Dynamic with Husband – Photos and Video

May 05, 2026

Bonnie Tyler's Family Shares Heartbreaking News After Singer's Sudden Death in Portugal — What Led to This Moment

July 09, 2026