3 Stories about Unexpected Finds in Old Cheap Houses

Picture finding a surprising secret in a quiet corner of your home. That is exactly what happened to the folks in these stories, who found amazing things hidden in their simple houses.

They initially believed their old, affordable homes were just full of old memories and, well, some clutter waiting to be cleared. But they were in for a shock. Hidden within walls and under floors, they found remarkable treasures that turned their lives around in the most unexpected ways. Let's dive into their stories.

1. My Wife and I Thought We Bought a Cheap Old House until We Entered Its Basement

The wooden stairs creaked, and dust and a musty stench of mold assaulted my senses as Kara and I descended the basement of our new house. Old boxes, broken furniture, and debris lay scattered around.

"Do you think that old lady sold us the house for cheap just to have us clean out her trash?" I frowned, seeing the mess.

"Who cares? Some of this stuff could be worth something," Kara shrugged.

I nodded with a sigh and accompanied my wife in cleaning our new home, starting with the cellar. Hours of dusty chores later, I stumbled upon a strange wooden door in the basement wall.

The door didn't budge when I tugged gently on the handle. It took a hard tug to get it open.

"Kara, come here! Check this out," I shouted. "I found something."

As Cara leaned forward and shone the flashlight across the eerie darkness, we saw a large wooden chest sitting in the middle of the cellar, cloaked in cobwebs and dust.

"That's a strange chest!" I grimaced. "What do you think is inside?"

"There's only one way to find out. Let's crack it open!" Kara said.

After a tedious effort, I cracked the box open, only to leap back in shock. "I guess we found the old woman's antique figurine collection," I said as I held a ceramic statuette.

Kara took the statuette from my grasp, and her eyes widened in surprise.

"Babe, we need to see what else is in there," she said. "If I'm right, then we've found a real treasure! Meissen...and, oh, look at this! Dresden Lace! They're so pretty. I want to keep all of them."

But I dismissed Kara's idea as I looked up the figurines online. "They could be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, and they don't belong to us. How did they even end up here in this cellar?" I wondered.

"Do you think they were stolen?" Kara doubted.

We suspected the fortune in our grasp was unlikely to have belonged to the woman who had sold her house for a cheap bargain. After a deep discussion, Kara and I decided to sell the figurines in Pennsylvania (in a different state) and get enough money to square away all our debts and start a new life.

Decision made, Kara stayed back to tidy up the house while I set out on the highway alone, the whopping find stashed in my car trunk.

About half an hour later, I'd just passed Lake Milton when my phone suddenly rang.

"Honey, there was a..." Kara panted and cried. "...there was a thief in the house. I took your rifle and went down the basement..."

My heart started pounding as I pulled over to the curb. "What? You're okay, right?"

Kara sniffled. "Yeah...he ran at me, and I pulled the trigger. It scared him off. He high-tailed it back out the window. But, honey, he was searching for something around the exact spot where we found the chest last night."

"What? Lock all the doors. I'm coming!"

Overwhelmed by fear, I quickly turned around and sped home.

"It's okay… I'm here… it's okay," I hugged Kara tightly as soon as I arrived home. She was too terrified. Although I wanted to leave the figurines somewhere so the stranger who broke into our house could retrieve them, I changed my mind.

"This house is ours, and everything inside is also ours," I declared. "And after how he scared you, I'm not letting him have what we found… I think I know a way we can still keep the treasure."

I devised a plan so that the burglars or whoever was after the figurines would never come back looking for them. "We'll move to a new city and start over with the money we make from selling the figurines," I said confidently.

"Yes, you're right," Kara added. "Why should we just give up on something that we found in our house? I think the only way to get rid of those thieves is to make them believe that the figurines were destroyed."

I agreed with Kara.

Later that night, we swapped the figurines in the chest with our old ceramic plates and cups. We went from room to room and doused the furniture with gasoline and almost all flammable liquids we had.

Satisfied with our ingenious plan, I sparked my lighter and tossed it into the house. "I wish we didn't have to do this," I said as Kara and I ran to our car and drove away from our house that was burning down.

"It'll be impossible to tell that the shattered and charred ceramicware in there isn't from those figurines!" Kara chuckled as I nodded behind the wheel. We crashed for the night at a motel on the highway, where we planned our future with the fateful fortune in our possession. But for some reason, Kara was skeptical if it would work.

"Have we crossed the line, babe?" Kara looked up at me as we retired to our motel room.

"I don't think so! We're just helping ourselves," I said.

"But it's not like those figurines are really ours," Kara said, and I could feel she was scared. "What if they were stolen? We should turn them in to the cops."

"Really? I don't think so," I said. "We've come too far to turn back now, Kara. We'll sell these figurines, buy a cozy little house with the money we get, and just move on."

Although Kara agreed, thinking of how our life would change overnight for good, something bothered her.

"Today, we burned down our house. What about tomorrow? What if those men come searching for the treasure?" she asked, looking at me.

"I know, babe. But don't you want our dream house? Something little… and cozy where we could start over… have kids… and be happy for the rest of our lives?" I said.

"Of course, I do, honey," Kara held my hand. "I'm just saying that maybe we should stop everything before it's too late. It's better to stop in time than to regret it later."

"You're just overthinking," I gently kissed Kara's forehead to comfort her. "But I hear you, alright? We're almost finished with this business. I'll sell those figurines tomorrow, and we will leave this place."

The following morning, I left Kara at the motel and took the figurines to an antique dealer in town.

"Uhm...how did you get these?" Mr. Finch, the antique dealer, skeptically asked as he studied the details engraved on the ceramic items.

A weird sensation crawled up my gut. But I kept calm and looked Mr. Finch in the eye. "Oh, they're part of a collection that belonged to my late grandmother," I said.

"Hmm, I'll give you $200 for the figurines and $10,000 for the entire collection," Mr. Finch said, and my brows shot up in shock.

"What? You can't be serious," I shook my head. "I'll find another buyer if you aren't ready to pay the hundreds of thousands its worth."

"It's not an offer," Mr. Finch said. "I know these figurines were stolen. If you don't sell them to me for $10,000, I'll report you to the cops."

My face twisted with shock, and I forced a smile onto my face, trying to cloak my fear. "Oh, you're mistaken...I got to go," I said.

"Oh, I'm not! The ball's in your court now. You have until this evening to decide," Mr. Finch replied.

Without giving a reply, I hurried out of the store with the box of figurines. But I was scared. It was a small town. "What if Mr. Finch knew the burglars? He would tell them the figurines weren't destroyed in the fire. Kara and I should leave this town immediately," I muttered as I sped to the motel.

But when I rushed to my room, I was in for a massive shock. Kara was not there. Clothes lay strewn across the floor. The mattress and pillows were sliced open. And there was a sticky note on the TV.

"Do exactly what we say if you want your lady back alive."

A cold sweat broke onto my forehead as I read the rest of the note: "Bring the figurines to the abandoned warehouse on Elm Street at midnight. Don't try to act smart and involve the cops. Or Kara will pay for your disobedience. You'll get 25 percent of the value of the figurines if you do as instructed."

I regretted leaving Kara alone, and it was like a boulder rolling downhill.

Crumpling the note and tucking it into my pocket, I drove back to the antique store just as Mr. Finch locked it up.

"Oh, I see you made a smart decision," Mr. Finch grinned wickedly.

"Now, give me the money," I said as Mr. Finch unlocked the antique store and beckoned me inside.

He inspected every inch of the figurines one by one and wrote a check for $10,000.

"It was a pleasure doing business with you, Mr. Finch," I said with a smile. I hopped into my car and hurried past the store to Elm Street to settle my scores with the thugs who had held Kara captive.

My heart hammered in my chest as I stepped into the dark warehouse on the outskirts of town an hour later. I peered inside and saw Kara surrounded by several gangsters.

"Aaron!" Kara cried and tried to run toward me. But her might was nothing compared to the menacing thug that stopped her.

"Not so fast, lady! Where are the items?" the guy turned to me.

"It's in the car," I lied. "I wanted to see my wife first."

"Well, you've seen her now. Now go fetch our stuff," the thug told me.

Just then, police sirens blared outside. "Attention! This is the police. We have you surrounded. Discard your weapons and lie down on the ground," a commanding officer announced over a megaphone.

Half an hour later, Kara and I were standing in the police station, waiting for an update from the cops.

"I'm so confused...why did you do this?" Kara looked up at me, frowning.

"It's better to stop in time, remember?" I said. "I've never been so afraid all my life than when I saw you were gone, Kara. I just did what you would have done. I called the cops and played a part in their operation to catch these lowlifes."

"But I had to make a small stop on the way to ensure the antique dealer didn't miss out on his jail time!" I chuckled.

A while later, a police officer called Kara and me to take our statement before dropping a bombshell on us.

"The ringleader of this operation is the grandson of the elderly lady you bought that house from," the officer revealed. "He had no clue she would sell her house until it was too late for him to recover his stash of stolen figurines that were loaned from a private collector."

Disappointment and disbelief gripped Kara and me when the cop added, "We have a charge of arson to discuss, don't we?"

"The inspectors checked your property and immediately realized that the house fire resulted from arson," the officer stared at Kara and me. "Charges will have to be pressed."

Given the complexity of the situation and the involvement of multiple parties, the investigation into the arson took several months. Ultimately, the evidence led away from Kara and me, showing we were unintended victims of a larger criminal operation.

Cleared of any wrongdoing, we were able to use the insurance money to rebuild our lives. We decided to move to a new town, where we bought a small, cozy home and focused on fresh beginnings, cherishing the peace and security we had fought so hard to regain.

2. My Kids and I Relocated to a Cheap House after I Divorced, What I Found There Changed Our Lives Forever

I moved in with my parents when my husband of ten years kicked me out and asked for a divorce. "I'm in love with someone else, and you need to leave," he told me.

"What about our kids? Where will we go?" I asked, desperate.

"I don't care. I never wanted them anyway. Leave!" he continued coldly.

I didn't have a choice. The house was in his name and most of the money. Luckily, my parents stepped in and helped me get settled in their house.

"This won't be for long, Mom. I'll work and save for a new place," I told my mother.

"Don't worry, sweetheart. My grandkids and you will always be welcome in this house," she assured me. But I didn't want to take advantage. My kids could be loud, and my parents needed peace in their home.

I used to be a stay-at-home mom because that's what my husband wanted. But I called a friend and got a job immediately. It wasn't a great salary, but I had been out of the workforce for a long time, so it was better than nothing.

After a few months, my mom and I started searching for cheaper homes. I discovered an old house for a great price, but apparently, no one wanted to buy it because it needed serious repairs.

"Are you sure this is the house you want?" my mom asked.

"I think it's perfect, Mom. It's big enough for the family, and I'll repair it slowly. There's no way I could afford a house like this one if it weren't in such shape. I'll be buying it directly from the bank. Apparently, the old owner died, and the bank repossessed it," I explained.

So, I placed an offer and got the house. We moved in, and my mom continued to help take care of the kids while I worked. My dad and I started renovating the house. It was a slow process, but we were getting through faster than I expected.

We decided that the old carpet needed to be replaced. But after removing a section of it in the master bedroom, I discovered a trap door.

"What could it be?" I wondered out loud.

"I don't know, Em. It could be a safe or a basement," my dad suggested.

"No one said anything about a basement in this house," I added. Hesitantly, we opened the door and discovered a staircase.

"See? It has to be a basement," my dad continued. "Let's check it out."

"I don't know. This is usually when things go bad in scary movies," I whispered.

"Oh, please, stop with that nonsense. Let's go," my father scoffed.

I followed him down to the basement with a flashlight. My dad got the only light bulb down there working, and we discovered canvases covered under blankets.

"Are these...paintings?" I asked more to myself.

"The old owner must have left them here," my dad said. "You might need to call the bank to inquire about it."

I followed my dad's advice, but the bank said I was now the legal owner of whatever I found in that house. The paintings were beautiful. I even brought some up and hung them around the house.

But there were so many, so I thought of selling a few for some profit. I took one for an appraisal at the local art gallery. "This painting is exquisite!" the expert named Nick said. "Based on the signature, they belonged to André Mossé."

"Who is that?" I asked.

"He was a rising artist in Paris but only showed a few of his paintings before he went underground. No one knew what happened. Some believed he came to America and died here. I guess that's true," Nick explained.

"Are they valuable?" I wondered.

"I believe so. I'll have to check with my colleagues. But you say you have several of these at home?" he asked me.

"I must have at least 20 paintings or so," I replied.

He went to talk to his colleagues, and when he returned and told me the real value of the paintings, I almost fainted. "Ma'am. You're sitting on a gold mine!" he said.

I invited him to my house to show some of the other paintings, and his initial assessment was correct. They were worth a fortune. So, I sold a few to his art gallery.

I used some of the money to finish repairing the house and set up college funds for my children. I also hired a lawyer to get my cheating husband to pay child support.

While the paintings did make me financially strong, I believe the best thing I gained out of everything was Nick.

Yes. Eventually, Nick and I fell in love. And I can assure you, he's the best, best husband in the world. We recently welcomed a daughter, and my life feels complete.

Sometimes, God takes away something because he wants us to have something more precious. For me, it was Nick and building a loving family with him. I'm so glad I bought that old house. It brought me only good luck and happiness.

3. I Was Kicked Out of My Parents' Cheap, Old House after Their Deaths, Then I Discovered a Hidden Cellar There

I had to live independently at the age of 20 after my parents died in a car accident two years ago. While they left me with their house, they also left me with a lot of debt.

To avoid being chased by loan sharks, I dropped out of school and started working to pay off my parents' debts.

Unfortunately, no matter how hard I worked, it wasn't enough, and one day, the court seized my property. I was in tears, as I had nowhere to go.

My friend, Amara, saw the whole ordeal and rushed to my side. "I'm sorry this is happening to you," she said, embracing me. "You can stay at my apartment for the time being," Amara offered.

"Thank you, Amara. I appreciate this a lot," I sobbed. That day, Amara helped me pack my things as the officials who evicted me said the new owner of the property wanted to have it fixed right away.

While I was collecting my things, the new owner of the property suddenly arrived. He acted very arrogantly, laughing at me as I dumped my things into boxes.

"Ah, finally. I can get rid of this ugly house and build a nice modern mansion. This house stood out like a sore thumb in this neighborhood," he said, looking down at me.

He was accompanied by the builders he hired to demolish my house. Unlike the owner, they felt bad for me as I was kicked out of the only home I'd ever known.

To make me feel better, one of them decided to speak up. "This is actually quite a nice house. It was built well, and it's one of the first properties to be built in this town. It's a pity we're demolishing it," he said.

The new owner shot him a look and shrugged. "Eh, just get to work as soon as they're gone," he said before leaving the property.

After a couple of minutes, I took one last look at my house. I was heartbroken and couldn't help but sob. Although I was free of my parents' debts, my salary was not enough for me to rent another place. I couldn't help but wonder whether I'd end up on the streets.

Before I left, I gave the builders my phone number in case I accidentally left anything behind. Then I left with Amara and never looked back.

However, a couple of days later, a man called me. "Hi, is this Cindy? This is Jack. I'm one of the builders you saw at your house a couple of days ago."

"Oh, hello, Jack! Did I leave something there?" I asked.

"Well, not exactly. But I thought this was something you should know. When we started the demolition job, we discovered a hidden cellar through a hatch in the basement," he explained. "It's best you come to the house. It had a lot of your childhood photos and some other things. I think someone deliberately left them here for you," Jack said.

After ending the call, I immediately made my way back to my house. I was greeted by Jack, who looked to be a couple of years older than me. He led me to the basement and showed me the secret hatch he was talking about.

It led me to a very well-maintained room with furniture, boxes of antiques, and a table with old photographs of me with my grandfather. "If you look inside that box, you'll find things that might ease your burdens," Jack said, pointing to a chest at the foot of the table.

When I opened the chest, I was surprised to see a lot of gold jewelry inside. I recognized some of my grandmother's jewelry from old photos I used to see, as well as the gold watch my grandfather always used to wear. There were also rolls of money and documents for a property in a nearby town.

Under the documents was a note that read "For Cindy."

When Jack saw it, he decided to give me some privacy by leaving the secret room and heading back to the basement. After he left, I started reading:

"Dearest Cindypie,

I made this room a long time ago after I realized I would not be able to give you my estate in peace. When your grandma died, you were only a few months old. You became my happiness and my world. We had many wonderful memories, didn't we?

I wanted to make sure you had everything you needed until you grew up. However, greed can make people selfish, and that's exactly what happened to your parents. As painful as it may sound, they threatened to kill me if I did not leave my entire inheritance to them. So, what I did was I left them with some money and kept everything valuable inside this hidden room so that one day you may find it. I thought if I didn't listen to them, they would hurt you, too.

Remember what I always used to tell you, Cindypie? "To find something, you need to dig as deep as possible, even when there is no hope anymore." I hope you find this, Cindypie. May you always be safe, healthy, and happy.

Lots of love,

Grandpa."

When I reached the end of the letter, I was in tears. After my grandfather passed away when I was 14, there was not a day I didn't miss him. In fact, I was closer to him than I was to Mom and Dad, as they were always out of town and often neglected their duties as my parents.

After Grandpa died, my parents received a large amount of money from him. Since then, they started gambling and spending money like there was no tomorrow. This lifestyle left them in debt – a debt that I had to continue paying even after they died two years ago.

I spent a couple more minutes inside the room, looking at my pictures with my grandfather. I decided to keep them all, carefully placing them in boxes so that I could transfer them to the home he had purchased for me.

That night, Jack offered to help me transfer the things to my property in a nearby town. We ended up having dinner after that and getting to know one another.

I realized that Jack had been honest and sincere, as he could have easily kept the jewelry and money for himself. But he informed me about the hidden treasures.

Jack and I started to date. We got to know each other well and realized we were both really good people who were compatible with one another. A couple of years later, we got married and lived together in the house that my grandfather left me.

What I want to say is that things always get better. I was worried about how I would survive after losing my house and the money I earned to pay off my parents' debts. In the end, my grandfather surprised me with an inheritance I never knew about.

As these incredible stories show, sometimes the most extraordinary discoveries lie hidden in the most familiar places. For the people in the stories above, their homes held mysteries and memories that turned lives around in pleasant ways.

We're curious — do you have such a story, too? We'd love to hear it!

Tell us what you think about these stories, and share them with your friends.

If you enjoyed reading these, you might also enjoy these three stories where people learned shocking truths about their relatives only after their deaths.

If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.

Note: These pieces are inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only.