Carrie Underwood | Source: Getty Images
'American Idol' Judge Carrie Underwood's Glam Selfie Leaves Fans Divided — Photos
A glamorous selfie meant to drum up votes for the hit singing competition turned into a whole conversation about makeup, recognition, and natural beauty.
Advertisement
On April 27, 2026, Carrie Underwood took to Instagram to remind her followers to tune in and vote on "American Idol." What she probably didn't expect was that the photo itself would be much more concerning to her followers.
The selfie shows Underwood in full glam mode: sleek honey-blonde hair swept back with the rest falling straight over her shoulders, paired with voluminous lashes, smoky eyeshadow, and a glossy nude lip.
She paired the polished beauty look with a casual dark navy crew-neck tee, holding her hand up toward the camera with five fingers spread wide. The caption was straightforward. She wrote, "It's super important for you all to vote for your favorites to make the Top 5 on #AmericanIdol tonight!"
Simple enough, but the comments section had other plans. The responses were split pretty sharply between worry and defense.
"Omg what happened to Carrie underwood [sic]," questioned one netizen. Another echoed the sentiment, "I would not have even recognized her had the name not been on here." Someone else wondered, "Is that really Carrie??"
Advertisement
One fan took it a step further, sharing a story that quickly got attention. "I showed my husband this picture and I asked him who it was and he had no idea. After I told him he argued w me telling me it's not her! So I ended up showing him her name at the top [sic]," they wrote.
Others went a bit softer but stayed in the same lane. "I don't even recognize her anymore!" one person exclaimed, while another appealed directly to the star, "Oh Carrie… Go back to your natural beauty. You don't need all that makeup and stuff. You're naturally so beautiful."
Not everyone was on board with the criticism. Some fans pushed back, and they weren't subtle about it. "Wow. That's comments are so RUDE! She's beautiful! [sic]" one commenter fired back.
Another offered a practical explanation for Carrie Underwood's heavy makeup: "Guys. When people have to be on camera, make-up is heavy so your fave can be seen from far away. Be kind." And one fan kept it short and sweet, simply saying, "Beautiful human."
2005
Advertisement
Carrie Underwood during the American Idol Top 12 Finalists party at Astra West on March 9, 2005, in West Hollywood, California.
2006
Carrie Underwood during the Clive Davis Pre-GRAMMY Awards Party at Beverly Hilton in Beverly Hills, California, on February 7, 2006.
Advertisement
2007
Carrie Underwood at the 49th annual Grammy Awards at Staples Center on September 11, 2007, in Los Angeles, California.
2008
Carrie Underwood attends the 42nd Annual CMA Awards at the Sommet Center on November 12, 2008, in Nashville, Tennessee.
Advertisement
2009
Carrie Underwood onstage at the 43rd Annual CMA Awards at the Sommet Center on November 11, 2009, in Nashville, Tennessee.
2010
Carrie Underwood poses in the press room at the People's Choice Awards at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live on January 6, 2010, in Los Angeles, California.
Advertisement
2015
Carrie Underwood attends Almay Fresh-Faced Beauty Day on October 21, 2015, in New York City.
2020
Carrie Underwood attends the 54th annual CMA Awards at the Music City Center on November 11, 2020, in Nashville, Tennessee.
Advertisement
2021
Carrie Underwood performs onstage at the Academy of Country Music Awards at the Grand Ole Opry on April 18, 2021, in Nashville, Tennessee.
2022
Carrie Underwood and Mike Fisher attend the 56th Annual CMA Awards at Bridgestone Arena on November 9, 2022, in Nashville, Tennessee.
Advertisement
2023
Carrie Underwood at the CMT Music Awards held at Moody Center on April 2, 2023, in Austin, Texas.
2024
Carrie Underwood performs onstage for "Reflection: The Las Vegas Residency" at Resorts World Las Vegas on March 6, 2024, in Las Vegas, Nevada.
Advertisement
2025
Carrie Underwood during the "American Idol" Hollywood Week In Music City - Part 1 at the Grand Ole Opry on November 9, 2025, in Nashville, Tennessee.
2026
Is she really "unrecognizable"? Let us know!
Advertisement
Advertisement
