‘Survivor’ Jonny Fairplay & His Grandma’s Drama — From Faking Her Death for Votes to Getting Arrested for Alleged Larceny

Jonny Fairplay became famous in the world of reality shows for many reasons, including his ability to lie and steal. Here’s how far Fairplay was willing to go to earn votes from fans.

When actors think of their proudest moment on national television, it probably would not be trying to con the whole world into believing that a close relative was dead just to earn pity and votes, but for a certain reality show contestant, tricking the world is his proudest moment.

In 2003, a charming yet mischievous Jon Dalton aka, Jonny Fairplay, gained a shady reputation when he appeared on "Survivor: Pearl Islands," where he got a friend to lie that his grandmother had died.

Jonny Fairplay during Survivor Guatemala Finale Wrap Party at The Red Buddha Lounge in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Jonny Fairplay during Survivor Guatemala Finale Wrap Party at The Red Buddha Lounge in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Fairplay orchestrated what show host Jeff Probst called the greatest lie ever told on "Survivor: Pearl Islands." During the "loved ones" visit, Fairplay’s friend falsely announced that the former contestant’s grandmother had just died, a move he made to gain pity from contestants to win.

Fairplay’s tribemate teared up on hearing the supposedly sad news and allowed him to win the subsequent reward so he could find out more about his grandmother’s death.

Jonny Fairplay during E! Entertainment Kill Reality Premiere in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Jonny Fairplay during E! Entertainment Kill Reality Premiere in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Later on, Fairplay revealed his granny was alive and well. Speaking on his antics, Fairplay noted that he thought outside the box as he wanted to create the first real villain on a reality show.

After his time on "Survivor," Fairplay came back for "Survivor: Micronesia" but then asked to be voted out first.

His deceptive skills helped him secure a third position on the show, but that was not the last time the world heard of Fairplay and his supposed dead grandmother.

Jonny Fairplay during Silver Spoon Pre-Emmy Hollywood Buffet - Day 1 in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Jonny Fairplay during Silver Spoon Pre-Emmy Hollywood Buffet - Day 1 in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

According to reports, the reality star was arrested alongside his mother Patsy for stealing housing items, and a necklace from his grandmother, who he claimed was dead. 

Fairplay’s aunt accused him of taking advantage of his granny’s dementia and stealing bar stools, a leather chair, an end table, and a silver necklace with $5k from her house.

Jonny Fairplay during 2005 Stuff Style Awards - Portraits at Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Jonny Fairplay during 2005 Stuff Style Awards - Portraits at Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Fairplay and his mom were booked for larceny, but the former reality star maintained his innocence. Later on, it was reported that the case against Fairplay and his mom had been dismissed.

After his time on "Survivor," Fairplay came back for "Survivor: Micronesia" but then asked to be voted out first so he could be with his pregnant girlfriend. 

Jonny Fairplay during VH1 Big in '05 - Backstage and Audience at Sony Studios in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

Jonny Fairplay during VH1 Big in '05 - Backstage and Audience at Sony Studios in Los Angeles, California | Photo: Getty Images

These days, the former contestant enjoys trying wrestling and being a parent to his kids, but he still looks back on his reality days with a smile.

ⓘ NEWS.AMOMAMA.COM does not support or promote any kind of violence, self-harm, or abusive behavior. We raise awareness about these issues to help potential victims seek professional counseling and prevent anyone from getting hurt. NEWS.AMOMAMA.COM speaks out against the above mentioned and advocates for a healthy discussion about the instances of violence, abuse, sexual misconduct, animal cruelty, abuse etc. that benefits the victims. We also encourage everyone to report any crime incident they witness as soon as possible.

Related posts
LeVar Burton Found Out He Had a Child 3 Years after the Kid Was Born – Meet His Grown-Up Son
Getty Images
Hollywood Aug 08, 2021
LeVar Burton Found Out He Had a Child 3 Years after the Kid Was Born – Meet His Grown-Up Son
Man Frames Housekeeper to Fool His Wife, Karma Punishes Him Hard - Subscriber Story
Shutterstock
Inspirational Stories Jul 03, 2021
Man Frames Housekeeper to Fool His Wife, Karma Punishes Him Hard - Subscriber Story
Luther Vandross' Sexual Orientation Remained A Secret Until Patti LaBelle's Revelation After His Death
Getty Images
Musicians Jul 02, 2021
Luther Vandross' Sexual Orientation Remained A Secret Until Patti LaBelle's Revelation After His Death
Woman Hides Her Child from Her Husband for 10 Years - Story of the Day
Getty Images
Inspirational Stories May 26, 2021
Woman Hides Her Child from Her Husband for 10 Years - Story of the Day