Father Makes Daughter Wear ‘Ugly’ Clothes to School as Punishment, Readers Claim He Should Be More Strict

• A dad decided to punish his 15-year-old fashionista daughter by making her wear ugly clothes to school for an extended period.
• The 15-year-old girl was miserable, saying she's never been so insecure.
• Despite the dad feeling bad, people slammed him for the weak punishment he gave, thinking the girl should have been given a more challenging sentence for what she did.

A man's daughter grew up to love fashion like her mother. The 15-year-old, Lily, had a gorgeous designer clothing collection, just like her mother.

While the man never intended to spoil his 15-year-old, he and his wife indulged her because she excelled academically and was generally well-behaved.

One day, despite Lily being at the top of all her classes, the proud parents were called into the teacher's office after discovering that Lily and her friends had been bullying another girl. To make matters worse, teachers determined that Lily was the ringleader.

Lily's bullying was so grave that the school would've expelled her if it weren't for her academic track record. Furious, the parents were determined to teach her a lesson.

The Parents Believed Lily Needed a Punishment

The parents offered two punishments: either they took away her phone, and she'd lose contact with friends for an extended period, or she'd have to wear "ugly" clothes for the same period.

With much hesitation, Lily chose the second punishment. They padlocked the young girl's wardrobe after putting out some plain tracksuits and shirts that had accumulated dust from barely being worn.

Through it all, Lily didn't try to hide her disappointment. Fashion was a huge part of her life; she saw it as a way to express herself.

Lily was the type of girl to dress her best for a quick errand trip. She hated her punishment, but it was much better than the first one offered, meaning she'd miss out on all her friends.

While the dad didn't plan to stop the punishment, he wondered whether he was too mean.

After imposing the punishment, Lily's dad got a call from his sister. The sister revealed Lily called her crying about not being able to wear her nice clothes.

The Dad Started Feeling Bad

Lily likened the punishment to prison because she had no freedom of expression. Lily's concerned aunt added that she'd never heard her niece so upset.

"Lily feels vulnerable and insecure in the clothes we made her wear," the dad explained. While the dad didn't plan to stop the punishment, he wondered whether he was too mean.

He's determined to punish Lily for bullying another girl but doesn't want her to feel upset and vulnerable constantly. Torn, he turned to the internet to find answers to whether his punishment was too harsh.

What Did People Think of the Situation?

To his surprise, people slammed him for the "weak" punishment he imposed on his daughter. One said taking away nice clothes could be a punishment for acting out during dinnertime but not for bullying someone who couldn't defend herself.

"What kind of weak [expletive] punishment is that for leading a group of kids to bully and harass another? Be better Dad, she isn't going to learn a thing and sounds like she hasn't so far," one user commented.

"It's a very weak punishment, though. She was almost EXPELLED for what she said and did to another child! Can you even begin to imagine how upset and vulnerable that girl felt?!?" another echoed.

The dad has yet to respond to comments about his dilemma. Despite that, people shared their thoughts with him, especially after he thought his punishment was too harsh when, based on other people's point-of-view, it wasn't.

If you were the dad, what would you have done? Do you think he was too harsh, or was his punishment too lenient?

In a similar story, a furious dad forced his 16-year-old daughter to sleep in the backyard as punishment for bullying their housekeeper. Click here to find out what happened.