Aaron Carter's Controversial Career and Unexpected Engagement after Breakup

Aby Rivas
Jun 25, 2020
11:30 A.M.

Aaron Carter first came into the spotlight thanks to his brother, Backstreet Boys' member Nick Carter. But as time passed, and as Aaron came into his own person, his headlines turned muddy, and he built the reputation of a bad boy.


There was a time when Aaron Carter was a heartthrob who could make girls faint with his smile and scream as he sang sappy pop songs on stage.

Aaron Carter at "The Night Time Show" Holiday Special on Dec. 16, 2017 in Hollywood, California | Photo: Getty Images

Aaron Carter at "The Night Time Show" Holiday Special on Dec. 16, 2017 in Hollywood, California | Photo: Getty Images

Aaron started following his famous brother's steps into the music industry when he was a teenager. Still, as he hit his twenties, his career hit a brick wall, and his reputation took several blows.

The now 32-year-old star was once synonymous with music, blonde locks, and a charming personality. Now, his name is associated with drugs, mental health issues, and a complicated relationship with his family.



Born on December 6, 1987, in Tampa, Florida, Aaron is one of Jane Elizabeth and Robert Gene Carter's five children. Aside from his brother Nick, he has three more sisters.

In September 2019, Nick Carter and his sister Angel were granted a restraining order against Aaron.

Aaron showed his interest in music from a young age, an interest that grew when Nick joined the Backstreet Boys in 1993.

Backstreet Boys perform on ABC's "Good Morning America" at SummerStage at Rumsey Playfield, Central Park on July 13, 2018 in New York City. | Photo: GettyImages

Backstreet Boys perform on ABC's "Good Morning America" at SummerStage at Rumsey Playfield, Central Park on July 13, 2018 in New York City. | Photo: GettyImages

At age 9, Aaron made his first performance on stage while visiting Germany during one of his brother's group's tour stops.

One of the managers of the Backstreet Boys saw potential in a young Aaron, and allowed him to go in front of the audience for a rendition of the Jets' "Crush On You."


Years later, Aaron would refer to the performance as "kind of like a joke," but it landed him a recording contract with a European label.

He released his self-titled first studio album in 1997, and started amassing a legion of fans that grew even more with the release of his second album, "Aaron's Party (Come Get It)" in 2000.


Around that time, Aaron opened concerts for the Backstreet Boys and Britney Spears, and he became a Disney-certified heartthrob when he made his acting debut on "Lizzie McGuire."

His third album, "Oh Aaron," went platinum in the U.S in 2001, and his last studio album under Jive Records, "Another Earthquake!" was released in 2002 but failed to duplicate its predecessor's success.

"Another Earthquake!" was Aaron's last studio album for almost sixteen years, until he released "LøVë" under Sony Music in 2018.



Aaron's squeaky clean reputation started to crumble when he got involved in a teenage love triangle with Hilary Duff and Lindsay Lohan in the early 2000s. This led to a feud between the girls until Aaron eventually broke things off with Lohan.

In 2006, Aaron joined Nick and the rest of his siblings on the reality TV show "House of Carters," which aired on E! and allowed fans to see the sometimes-complicated nature of the brothers' relationship.

That same year, Aaron made headlines when he proposed to girlfriend and Playboy model Kari Ann Peniche at 18 years old.


However, the engagement lasted only one week, after which Aaron retracted his proposal claiming he was still too young and that it had been a rushed decision. By then, Aaron still had some loyal fans, but critics were starting to note his character decadence.

Two years later, Aaron had his first encounter with the law. He was pulled over for speeding and then arrested when police officers found two ounces of weed in his car.


His father told People magazine at the time that he was "totally floored" by Aaron's arrest, claiming that some people had warned him there was something off with Aaron, but he didn't want to believe it.

"Aaron has always thought he was invincible," Robert Carter said. "Sometimes it takes a knock in the head to get people back on track. I hope that's what happens here."


In 2009, Aaron competed on season 9 of "Dancing with the Stars" alongside professional dancer Karina Smirnoff. They finished in fifth place.

Aaron Carter arrives at the 52nd Annual GRAMMY Awards held at Staples Center on January 31, 2010 in Los Angeles, California. | Photo: GettyImages

Aaron Carter arrives at the 52nd Annual GRAMMY Awards held at Staples Center on January 31, 2010 in Los Angeles, California. | Photo: GettyImages

Aaron took advantage of the attention he received from the reality competition and tried to kickstart his music career again. Still, his singles didn't do well on the charts.


Two years later, Aaron entered a treatment program at the Betty Ford Center in Rancho Mirage, California. According to his manager, the singer was looking for guidance and healing from some emotional issues he was dealing with.

In 2013, Aaron filed for bankruptcy. He had a debt of more than $3.5 million, mostly from back taxes and $30,000 in credit card bills. He eventually settled the tax debt in 2014.



Aaron toured around the U.S and Canada and released various singles between 2015 and 2017. During that time, he raised concerns among fans for his frail figure, which he claimed was a product of a hiatal hernia that made it difficult to eat.

Then, in July 2017, he was pulled over in Georgia for speeding and subsequently arrested for suspicion of driving under the influence. Police found marijuana and drug-related objects in his car, but Aaron refused to take a drug test.


His then-girlfriend, Madison Parker, was with him and was also arrested under the same charges plus obstruction of law.

After posting bail, Aaron made it known through his publicist that he believed he had been targeted for being a celebrity, claiming he had a medical license to use marijuana for his anxiety.

Nick Carter took to Twitter at the time to send a message to his brother offering help, but Aaron clapped back, asking why Nick didn't contact him through a private outlet if he was so worried.


A month later, Aaron came into the spotlight once again when he claimed in a letter shared on Twitter that he found boys and girls attractive since he was 13.

He also revealed he had a relationship with a man at 17, which many people assumed was his way of coming out as bisexual. However, the following year, Aaron told Hollywood Life that his words had been misinterpreted.

"I can find men and women attractive, but when it comes down to it, I think it was a little misconstrued," he said. "I see myself being with a woman and having kids. I want to have a family."



In September 2017, Aaron checked in to a rehab facility for the second time after an appearance on the TV show "The Doctors." On the show, he submitted to several tests to dispel rumors about his health, mainly the one about him having AIDS.

On the show, Aaron was found to be underweight with a weak immune system. The doctors advised him to seek help and pause his fast-paced life so he could find inner peace.


Aaron returned to the show in 2019, to reveal he had been diagnosed with acute anxiety, multiple personality disorder, schizophrenia, and manic depression.

He also displayed a bag of his prescription meds, claiming he was only taking prescribed drugs to deal with his mental health. Aaron admitted he had a huffing addiction in the past, but said he had quit after his time in rehab in 2017.


In September 2019, Nick Carter and his sister Angel were granted a restraining order against Aaron, claiming that the 32-year-old had threatened Nick's pregnant wife and unborn child.

"Take care. @NickCarter we're done for life," Aaron said on Twitter about the situation. "I haven't seen him in four years. And I don't intend to."


Aaron started dating Melanie Martin in January 2020. The relationship progressed quickly, and in April, he announced they were expecting their first child.


However, that same month, the couple split for a while after Martin was arrested for a domestic violence incident, in which she allegedly left Aaron with visible scratches and bruises.

The couple rekindled their relationship in early June, with Aaron claiming he had never stopped loving Martin, and that she had taken responsibility for her actions.

He also shared the sad news that Martin had suffered a miscarriage, and announced their surprising engagement on Instagram just a few days later.

Aaron recently told People he's focused on the future and is working on new music. He also has a clothing line out and has been keeping his fans updated on his life and career through several YouTube live streams in the past months.

Please fill in your e-mail so we can share with you our top stories!
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy
Related posts

Aaron Carter’s Toddler Son Visits His Grave on Late Singer’s 1st Death Anniversary

November 07, 2023

Aaron Kendrick De Niro Is Robert De Niro's Son Born via Surrogate

January 15, 2024

My Husband's Mistress Had No Idea How I Looked, So I Came up with a Brilliant Revenge Plan

February 22, 2024

‘Wonder Woman’ Star Lynda Carter Shares Pain Following Husband’s Death – His Request Saved Their Marriage & Family

December 19, 2023

'Family Ties': What Happened to the Stars of the Iconic Series

November 11, 2023

Rosalynn Carter Was ‘Coming to the End’ but Still Held Hands with Her Husband — She Died at 2:10 p.m at Their Home

November 21, 2023

53-Year-Old Woman Gives Birth to Twins, Son-In-Law Notices Familiar Birthmarks on Them — Story of the Day

February 01, 2024

Woman Discovers That She Is Actually the Biological Mom of Her Adopted Son – Story of the Day

January 18, 2024

Melanie Griffith & Don Johnson’s Baby Was ‘God’s Plan’ — Now They’re Proud Parents of an ‘Extraordinary’ Daughter

November 24, 2023

Martin Luther King Jr.’s Youngest Son Dies at Home after Losing Battle with ‘Terrible Disease’: Details

January 23, 2024

How 5 Beloved Celebrities Would Look without Plastic Surgery — Photos via AI

February 28, 2024

These 5 Girls Are '90s Idols and One of Whom Is Married to a Famous Soccer Player – Quiz

December 20, 2023

Iggy Azalea's Husband: The Rapper Was Sued for Divorce & Has Been Single since 2020

November 13, 2023

'Final Days': Jimmy & Rosalynn Carter Were Together Under Hospice Care Surrounded by Family

November 19, 2023