Beyoncé Daughter's under Fire for Her 'Not Age Appropriate' Look At 12 — Girl's Transformation through Years

• From the moment of her birth, Blue Ivy, the daughter of Jay-Z and Beyoncé, has been in the limelight, gaining recognition as one of the world’s most famous infants.
• Her birth was described by her mother, Beyoncé, as the best day of her life, and she was featured in one of her father's songs when she was merely two days old.
• However, recently, the now twelve-year-old Blue Ivy has faced criticism over her appearance, which some have deemed, "not age appropriate."

The 12-year-old daughter of iconic powerhouse artist Beyoncé Knowles-Carter and rap icon Jay-Z Carter stole the show at this year's Grammy Awards. Blue Ivy Carter looked radiant in an elegant off-the-shoulder gown, which showed off her collar bones.

She paired her chic ensemble with light makeup, silver earrings, a ring, and a dainty clutch bag. Though the young star on the rise looked beautiful in the pictures of her with her mogul parents and other celebrities, some people did not agree with what she wore.

Of Blue Ivy's dress, one social media user asserted, "Not age appropriate at all!" Similarly, another expressed, "That dress is not for a 12 year old child." Someone else questioned, "Why is Blue's cleavage showing?"

Another Instagrammer who agreed with the inappropriateness of the dress said, "She's 12 looking 18." However, other people complimented Blue Ivy's appearance, citing that she looked great.

In this regard, one fan praised, "She is adorable and looks so poised 🙌." Another called her "so gorgeous." Speaking of the gown, an Instagrammer gushed, "The dress is cute!!! I prefer this rather than baggy jeans and XL t-shirts!"

This recent appearance at the Grammys is not Blue Ivy's first association with the prestigious event. A few years ago, the young performer made history when she became the second-youngest individual to win a Grammy for her mom's music video "Brown Skin Girl," as Blue Ivy was given writing credit for the track.

Despite being the child of a global superstar, Blue Ivy views Beyoncé simply as her mother. This grounded perspective likely contributes to her resilience in the face of criticism.

The birth of Blue Ivy Carter was one of the most anticipated events in celebrity history births. There were playful remarks suggesting that the infant would be born with innate musical talents, having the ability to rap and sing. So it was no surprise that her first cries were immortalized in her father's track "Glory."

Born to the powerhouse duo of Beyoncé and Jay-Z, Blue Ivy's arrival was heralded as the birth of the most famous baby in the world. Blue Ivy didn't just enter the world; she made an entrance. Her mother, Beyoncé, has openly admitted that the prospect of pregnancy was intimidating for her.

Upon arrival at the hospital, all of her apprehensions dissipated. Surrounded by her family and closest friends during the birth, she found that the elements that had previously terrified her were nowhere to be found in that room. This allowed her to embrace the experience fully, cherishing every contraction.

Reflecting on her daughter's birth, she said, "It was the best day of my life." From being tenderly shielded under a blanket to avoid the paparazzi's prying eyes, to her appearances in the public eye with her famous parents, the life of Blue Ivy has consistently captivated the public and been subjected to intense scrutiny.

Remarkably, she has made it into the Guinness World Records not once, but twice, for being the youngest person to achieve certain feats in music.

In 2013, Blue Ivy made history by becoming the youngest individual to have a song chart on any Billboard list, earning her a place in the Guinness World Records.

Blue Ivy at Two Years

At the 2014 MTV Video Music Awards, Blue Ivy and her father, Jay-Z, were seen among the audience, captivated by Beyoncé's performance. Following the performance, Jay-Z, cradling Blue Ivy, took to the stage, where he presented Beyoncé with the prestigious Michael Jackson Video Vanguard Award.

On February 8, 2015, Blue Ivy had a memorable encounter with Rihanna during the 2015 Grammy Awards. The meeting took place backstage, where Rihanna, elegantly dressed in a pink ball gown, bent down to chat with Blue Ivy, who was also fashionably attired in a pink outfit.

Blue Ivy at Three Years

Blue Ivy also graced the 2016 MTV Video Music Awards held at the iconic Madison Square Garden on August 28, 2016.

Blue Ivy at Four Years

On February 12, 2017, Blue Ivy, accompanied by her father Jay-Z, attended the 59th GRAMMY Awards. A week later, she joined her parents at the 66th NBA All-Star Game, a star-studded event held at the Smoothie King Center in New Orleans, Louisiana.

Blue Ivy at Five Years

On February 18, 2018, she was present at the 67th NBA All-Star Game, accompanied by her mother, Beyoncé, and her grandmother, Tina Knowles.

Blue Ivy at Six Years

In 2020, Blue Ivy was seen with her father at a basketball game between the Los Angeles Clippers and the Los Angeles Lakers.

Blue Ivy at Eight Years

In 2021, she entered the Guinness World Records for the second time after winning the Best Music Video award at the 63rd Annual Grammy Awards, where she was featured as an artist on her mother's song, "Brown Skin Girl."

In 2022, the father-daughter duo attended the NBA Finals, where the Boston Celtics faced off against the Golden State Warriors.

Blue Ivy at Ten Years

On February 12, 2023, Blue Ivy was spotted at the Super Bowl LVII in Glendale, Arizona.

Blue Ivy at 11 Years

Later in August, she joined her mother onstage during her "Renaissance World Tour" performance at the Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta, Georgia.

As previously reported on November 30, 2023:

As Beyonce marks another milestone in her career with the release of "Renaissance: A Film by Beyonce," her family has shown her full support. In the London premiere of the concert movie, her daughter Blue Ivy made sure to walk the red carpet with her famous mother.

For the occasion, Beyonce's eldest daughter, Blue Ivy, donned a black, off-shoulder dress and dark sunglasses. While the young lady looked mature and sophisticated in her all-black ensemble, fans didn't think it was appropriate.

"That kid is too young for that dress at 11 years old hanging off her shoulder," one user commented. "Don't understand why they want her to look like she is so much older," another echoed.

While others slammed Blue Ivy and Beyonce's seemingly inappropriate outfits, others felt people were too critical of the mother-and-daughter duo. Their fans showered them with support and love through their comments.

"Love this and Bey's silver look," one fan shared. "Love both of them so much beautiful," another fan praised. Regardless of what others had to say, their loyal fans made sure to silence haters with their supportive comments.

Blue Ivy played a part in her mom's "Renaissance" tour and concert movie. She appeared as one of the dancers in her mom's performances of "Black Parade" and "My Power."

Initially, Blue Ivy's dance performances were supposed to be a one-time thing. However, she insisted on wanting to join her mom's tour to perform. It took a lot of negotiating until Beyonce finally caved in.

Blue Ivy eventually contributed more than just her dancing skills. In the "Renaissance" film, she could be seen sharing her opinions on her mom's song choices, stage design, and more. She was candid with her thoughts, as, after all, to her, Beyonce was simply mom.

The young woman has made waves in the industry at her tender age. Before joining her mom on tour, she was already a Grammy Award winner. She won Best Music Video for "Brown Skin Girl," an achievement as few people can say they won a prestigious award at nine.

In May, Blue Ivy showcased her dancing skills as part of Beyoncé's ensemble, impressively mastering the choreography. That same month, she'd joined her mother and the dance troupe for a performance at a concert in Paris. Then in July, she once again shared the stage with her mother, this time in Philadelphia, even performing in heels.

Blue Ivy at 12 Years

Although Blue Ivy has already begun establishing herself as a force to be reckoned with in the entertainment industry, her loving parents haven't pushed her into pursuing careers like their own.

In a past interview, doting dad Jay-Z clarified that what is important to him and Beyoncé when raising their children is ensuring they "provide a loving environment" and "be very attentive to who they want to be." Jay-Z said, "It's easy for us, as human beings, to want our children to do certain things, but we have no idea. We're just guides."

The business mogul, who wants the best for his beloved children, was honored with the Dr. Dre Global Impact Award at the Grammy Awards. While holding his award and giving his acceptance speech, with his daughter standing next to him, the "Otis" artist joked, "I used to say this is a sippy cup for Blue, but Blue's grown up now; she doesn't take sippy cups, and she has her own Grammys."

Toward the end of his speech, Jay-Z Carter and Blue Ivy Carter shared a sweet moment when he took her hand and spoke about the importance of people continuing to show up for themselves.

Shortly after the Grammy Awards, Blue Ivy was spotted at Super Bowl LVIII at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, accompanied by her father and younger sister, Rumi Carter. The game was between the Kansas City Chiefs and the San Francisco 49ers. Both the renowned rapper and his younger daughter sported leather jackets for the occasion, while Blue Ivy opted for a classic letterman's jacket.

The young star's attire was met with approval from fans, who expressed their delight with comments such as, "It's great to see kids dressed like kids," "First time I ever say Blue Ivy just acting like a kid," and "Now that is what a twelve-year-old should be wearing. [sic]"

Blue Ivy has faced her fair share of criticism. However, she has never allowed it to discourage her. In fact, these critiques have played a crucial role in shaping her journey to refine her dancing skills. Initially, her performance was intended to be a one-time event. However, the feedback she received on social media about her dance moves spurred her to strive for improvement.

This criticism ignited a determination within her to train even more rigorously for future performances. Her active involvement and keen interest in various aspects of the performances, such as stage design and song choices, further indicate her commitment to her craft.